E-Paper Subscribe About

IndiaWatch

Truth  ·  Accountability  ·  Transparency

Democracy: buffering since 1947.
" Loading… Share
BREAKING
🔴 500+ detained near Jantar Mantar on 2 Oct at protests seeking CEC Gyanesh Kumar's resignation; CJP calls a fresh march for 10 OctSupreme Court hears on 5 Oct a plea asking whether the CEC can act without the other two Election Commissioners; ECI says decisions were unanimousUPI merchant fee starts 15 Oct: 0.4% MDR on payments to merchants above ₹2,000, paid by merchants, not customersUPI handled 24.07 billion payments worth ₹29.37 lakh crore in September, about 802 million a day (NPCI)Petrol ₹102.12 and diesel ₹95.20 in Delhi, unchanged on 3 Oct with Brent above $102 a barrelSonam Wangchuk gave the Centre until 2 Oct to show progress on Ladakh statehood, or peaceful protests resumeEducation Minister Dharmendra Pradhan resigned 25 July over NEET-UG 2026 paper leak; Pralhad Joshi now holds the portfolioIncome tax collected grew 3.5× since FY17, filers only 1.9×; about 2.8 crore people carry the billE20 ethanol petrol blending: mileage and vehicle-compatibility concerns keep policy under public scrutiny
UPI CHARGES
⛽ Petrolloading…
💵 USD/INRloading…
🏗₹7.2L Cr tracked
UPDATED · 3 OCT 2026

More than 500 detained near Jantar Mantar as protests demand Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar's resignation; Supreme Court hears a challenge on Monday

On Gandhi Jayanti, 2 October, Delhi Police detained more than 500 people heading to Jantar Mantar, including AAP's Atishi, Saurabh Bharadwaj and Sanjay Singh. Police said no permission had been given and prohibitory orders were in force; 12 metro stations were shut and mobile internet was suspended near the site. In Mumbai the Cockroach Janta Party rallied at Shivaji Park and said it will march to Jantar Mantar on 10 October if Kumar stays. On Monday, 5 October, a Supreme Court bench led by CJI Surya Kant hears a plea asking under what authority he acted without his two fellow Commissioners.

The protests follow an Indian Express investigation which says Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi objected at least 14 times over 10 months to orders on voter registration, deletions and voter-data systems, some taken without their knowledge. The ECI says differing views are a normal part of deliberation, not a rupture, and that all final decisions, including on SIR, were unanimous.

🗳 Election Watch LIVE
The Chief Election Commissioner, the law that chose him, and the questions over his tenure
14+
Objections by his own two colleagues (reported)
6.56 Cr
Names left off draft rolls, SIR phase 2
3
Removal notices filed in Parliament, 2026
Jan 2029
Term ends, days before 2029 poll schedule
🪪 Profile: Gyanesh Kumar

Gyanesh Kumar

26th Chief Election Commissioner of India
Born
27 January 1964, Agra (age 62)
Education
B.Tech, IIT Kanpur · course in environmental economics, Harvard
Service
IAS, 1988 batch, Kerala cadre
Retired from IAS
January 2024
Election Commissioner
15 March 2024
Chief Election Commissioner
19 February 2025
Term ends
26 January 2029
Appointed under
CEC & Other ECs Act, 2023, the first CEC chosen under it
Colleagues
ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi

How he got here

  • 1988 Joins the IAS, Kerala cadre. Serves in the state under both Left and Congress governments.
  • 1990 First posting as Sub-Collector, Pathanamthitta, Kerala.
  • 2012 Resident Commissioner, Kerala House, New Delhi.
  • May 2016 Joint Secretary, Kashmir Division, Union Home Ministry, under Home Minister Rajnath Singh.
  • 2019 After Amit Shah becomes Home Minister, works on drafting the J&K Reorganisation Bill that ended Article 370 and split the state into two Union Territories.
  • 2019–20 As Additional Secretary, handles the Ayodhya case files and helps constitute the Ram Janmabhoomi Teerth Kshetra Trust.
  • 2020 Left out when 24 officers of his 1988 batch are empanelled as Secretaries.
  • Feb 2021 Returns as Secretary, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, then Secretary of the new Ministry of Cooperation, headed by Amit Shah.
  • Jan 2024 Retires from the IAS as Cooperation Secretary.
  • 15 Mar 2024 Less than two months later, named Election Commissioner by a panel of PM Modi, Amit Shah and Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, who dissented. Oversees the 2024 Lok Sabha and the J&K, Haryana, Maharashtra, Jharkhand and Delhi polls.
  • 19 Feb 2025 Becomes CEC. The panel (Modi, Shah, Rahul Gandhi) met on 17 Feb and the appointment was notified that night, two days before a scheduled Supreme Court hearing on the law, over Gandhi's written dissent.
  • Dec 2025 Takes over as chair of the council of International IDEA, a global elections body, for 2026.
Sources: Outlook India (25 Sept 2026, profile drawing on The Indian Express) · News On AIR / PIB (18–20 Feb 2025) · The Tribune (Feb 2025, term to 26 Jan 2029) · ETV Bharat, Deccan Herald, Scroll, The News Minute (17–18 Feb 2025, selection and dissent) · Newslaundry (14 Mar 2024, Chowdhury dissent) · News On AIR (Dec 2025, International IDEA).
⚖ The Law That Chose Him, and Shields Him
WhenWhat changedWhy it matters
Mar 2023Supreme Court (Anoop Baranwal v Union of India) orders that, until Parliament makes a law, ECs be picked by the PM, the Leader of Opposition and the Chief Justice of India.The court stressed the ECI must be insulated from executive control.
Dec 2023Parliament passes the CEC & Other ECs Act. The CJI is replaced by a Union Cabinet minister nominated by the PM.The government now holds two of three votes on the panel. Justice Dipankar Datta observed in Sept 2026 that a minister "cannot be expected to defy his own nominator", making the opposition member "largely ornamental" (prima facie remarks).
12 Dec 2023Government adds Section 16 through a late amendment moved by Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal: no court may entertain civil or criminal proceedings against anyone who is or was a CEC or EC for acts in the course of official duty.Not in the original Bill. The government said it lets commissioners work "unhindered and independently". Critics say it is unusually broad and never expires.
2 Jan 2024Act comes into force. Two months later, Kumar and Sandhu become the first ECs chosen under it.The Supreme Court declined to stay those appointments but agreed to hear challenges.
Jan 2026Supreme Court issues notice on NGO Lok Prahari's challenge to Section 16, but refuses to stay it.Section 16 remains in force; no court has ruled on its validity.
23 Sept 2026Two-judge bench splits on whether the appointment law needs a Constitution Bench, and sends it to the CJI.More than two and a half years after the law took effect, its validity is still undecided.
29 Sept 2026A fresh petition seeks a writ of quo warranto, asking under what authority Kumar exercised on his own the powers Article 324 gives to the Commission as a body. CJI Surya Kant agrees to list it; the hearing is set for 5 October.The first case to put the reported dissent inside the Commission, not just the appointment law, before the court. The ECI says its decisions were unanimous.
  • Can he be arrested? Section 16 bars courts from hearing cases over official acts; it does not mention arrest or investigation, so how it applies would be for courts to decide.
  • Can he be removed? Only like a Supreme Court judge: a proved charge of "misbehaviour or incapacity" and a special majority in both Houses (Article 324(5) with 124(4)).
Sources: Outlook India (24 Sept 2026, "The Gyanesh Kumar Test", citing Rajya Sabha records of Amendment No. 39) · Outlook India (24 Sept 2026, "CJI Out, Minister In") · Outlook India (23 Sept 2026, "SIR To Removal Bid") · Bar and Bench, The Statesman (29 Sept 2026, quo warranto plea) · The Hans India (2 Oct 2026, listing for 5 Oct) · Supreme Court, Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (2 Mar 2023).
🕰 Under His Watch: The Controversies
DateWhat happenedECI / government response
Jun 2025Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter rolls starts in Bihar. About 65 lakh of 7.89 crore names are dropped from the draft roll.ECI says the rolls needed cleaning of dead, shifted and duplicate voters; names could be re-added during claims.
7 Aug 2025Rahul Gandhi alleges "vote chori" of 1,00,250 votes in Mahadevapura, Karnataka (duplicates, fake addresses, bulk registrations), and says the 2024 election was rigged.ECI asks him to sign a declaration or apologise. Karnataka CEO says a voter he named says she voted once.
17 Aug 2025In an unprecedented press conference, Kumar says Gandhi must file his claims under oath within 7 days or apologise, and calls "vote chori" an insult to the Constitution.Gandhi refuses, saying his oath as an MP is enough. Opposition asks why no affidavit was sought from BJP's Anurag Thakur for similar claims.
Oct 2025 – Apr 2026SIR phase 2 in 12 states and UTs. 6.56 crore names left off draft rolls, including 2.89 crore in UP and 58 lakh in West Bengal.ECI lists them as dead, shifted or duplicate; draft exclusion is not final deletion and anyone can reapply with Form 6.
5 Nov 2025Gandhi's "H-files" press conference alleges fake voters in Haryana and says CCTV footage is being destroyed.ECI says footage is kept for the 45-day election-petition window, citing voter privacy.
12 Mar 2026Opposition files removal notices in both Houses (130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha signatures), alleging partisan conduct.Rejected on 6 Apr by Speaker Om Birla and Chairman C.P. Radhakrishnan for lacking prima facie proof of misbehaviour.
24 Apr 2026Fresh Rajya Sabha notice with 73 signatures and nine charges.Pending.
May 2026BJP wins West Bengal for the first time after SIR. Opposition later demands fresh polls in Bengal and Bihar on pre-SIR rolls.No court has linked the results to the roll revision.
27 May 2026Supreme Court upholds ECI's power to run SIR in Bihar, with safeguards: Aadhaar accepted for identity, citizenship disputes go to the competent authority.A legal win for the ECI on its powers, with limits on how it checks citizenship.
Sept 2026Indian Express: ECs Sandhu and Joshi objected 14+ times, including to Form 6 changes Joshi said needed a rules amendment and Sandhu called "unauthorised" and "illegal", and to the "centralisation" of the voter database.ECI: differing views are normal and decisions were unanimous. Kumar has not personally responded.
23–26 Sept 2026Congress protests nationwide; Mamata Banerjee and Uddhav Thackeray demand his arrest; a plea in the Supreme Court seeks criminal proceedings; CJP sets a resignation deadline of 26 Sept.NDA ally Chirag Paswan asks the ECI to respond. Bengal BJP chief Samik Bhattacharya says Kumar deserves a Padma Bhushan for poll management.
2 Oct 2026Gandhi Jayanti protests in Delhi and Mumbai. More than 500 people are detained on the way to Jantar Mantar, including AAP's Atishi, Saurabh Bharadwaj and Sanjay Singh; 12 metro stations are shut and mobile internet is suspended nearby. CJP holds a "Jail Bharo" rally at Shivaji Park and calls a march to Jantar Mantar for 10 Oct. Reports now put names removed from draft rolls since 2025 at over 13 crore across 30 states and UTs.Delhi Police say the rally had no permission and Section 163 BNSS orders were in force. Mumbai Police say a 2013 High Court order bars them from allowing gatherings at Shivaji Park. Amnesty International calls the response an attack on the right to assemble. The ECI maintains the internal differences are not a rupture.
Sources: ANI, ThePrint, Deccan Herald (Aug 2025, press conference) · News On AIR (8 & 11 Aug 2025, ECI notices to Rahul Gandhi) · Deccan Herald (5 Nov 2025, "H-files"; Dec 2025–Jan 2026, SIR draft roll figures) · News On AIR (Dec 2025–Jan 2026, West Bengal and UP draft rolls) · Outlook India (23–25 Sept 2026) · CNBC (25 Sept 2026, CJP deadline) · Outlook India (2 Oct 2026, Jantar Mantar detentions) · Al Jazeera, ABC News Australia (2 Oct 2026, protests and internet suspension) · Amnesty International (2 Oct 2026) · NewsBytes (3 Oct 2026, 10 Oct march) · Wikipedia, "2025 Indian electoral controversy".
❓ Did He Return a Favour? What Each Side Says
What critics allege
  • His biggest career moves came under Amit Shah: Article 370, the Ayodhya trust, then the Cooperation Ministry. Shah then sat on the panels that picked him, twice.
  • He was appointed within two months of retiring, and made CEC at midnight two days before the Supreme Court was due to hear the challenge.
  • The ECI demanded an affidavit from the Leader of Opposition but not from BJP leaders making similar claims.
  • SIR removed crores of names before key elections, and his own colleagues say some decisions bypassed them.
  • A government-added clause protects him from lawsuits for life.
What the record also shows
  • No court, inquiry or parliamentary process has found wrongdoing. Removal notices were rejected for lack of prima facie proof.
  • The Supreme Court upheld the ECI's power to run SIR, and draft exclusions can be reversed on application.
  • Rahul Gandhi never filed the sworn declaration the ECI asked for.
  • The ECI says all its decisions were unanimous; the two commissioners' objections have not been published in full.
  • Opposition parties also won under him: Congress in Kerala, TVK in Tamil Nadu.

IndiaWatch presents the record, not a verdict. "Returned a favour" is an allegation made by opposition parties; it has not been tested or proven in any court.

🏛 Why "Democracy" Became the Word of His Tenure
  • Who picks the referee. Until 2023 the government alone chose election commissioners. The Supreme Court tried to change that by adding the CJI and the opposition leader; the 2023 law kept the opposition leader but gave the government two of the three seats. The court still hasn't ruled on whether that is allowed.
  • Who is on the roll. SIR is the largest rewrite of India's voter lists in decades. Supporters call it long-overdue cleaning; critics say the burden of proof shifted to voters, and the poor and migrants were most likely to drop off.
  • Whether the Commission speaks with one voice. Until now, dissent inside the ECI was rare and quiet. Two commissioners reportedly putting objections in writing, and going to the Cabinet Secretary, is new.
  • Whether the ECI is accountable. The immunity clause, the refusal to share CCTV footage beyond 45 days, and the press conference demanding an affidavit from the Leader of Opposition all fed a debate on how an independent regulator should answer criticism.
  • The other view. The government and the ECI argue that the Commission is under attack because it is cleaning rolls that benefited some parties, that elections under Kumar produced wins for opposition parties too, and that attacking the umpire undermines voter trust more than any roll revision.
What to watch: the Supreme Court hearing on 5 October on whether Kumar could act without his fellow Commissioners; CJP's march to Jantar Mantar on 10 October; the CJI's decision on a Constitution Bench for the appointment law; the separate plea for criminal proceedings; whether Kumar responds personally to the dissent report; and the pending Rajya Sabha removal notice.
💰 Money Watch LIVE
UPI charges and taxes, in one 2-minute read
0.4%
New UPI merchant fee, from 15 Oct
₹15-20k Cr
Est. yearly pool, to banks not govt
6.73%
Direct tax/GDP, FY25, up from 5.62% FY14 (CBDT)
₹44.04L Cr
Total tax govt aims to collect, FY27
UPI Was Free By Design. From October, Merchants Pay Again.
📜 UPI, in Brief
  • 2016: NPCI (an RBI/bank-owned non-profit) launched UPI to let anyone move money instantly by mobile number, part of a "less-cash," financial-inclusion push.
  • Its rocket growth is partly an accident of timing, UPI landed months before Nov 2016 demonetisation made cash scarce.
  • Today: 24.07 billion transactions worth ₹29.37 lakh crore in September 2026 alone, about 802 million a day; ~₹260 lakh crore moved in FY24-25.
  • Was it "promised free"? Yes, by policy, not law. Merchant fees (MDR) existed until the government zero-rated them in Jan 2020 to push digital adoption. The Finance Ministry denied any return of MDR/GST on UPI as recently as June 2025.
Sources: NPCI launch release (2016) · NPCI monthly data (Sept 2026, via Business Today and DD News) · India Stack · Tribune India & News on Air (Finance Ministry denials, Apr & Jun 2025) · Dept. of Financial Services.
💳 What Changes on 15 October
Who pays
Merchants only
Pass-through to customers is banned
Threshold
Above ₹2,000
95%+ of UPI payments stay free
Cap
₹300 / txn
On payments ₹75,000+
P2P transfers
Still free
Friends & family, unaffected
Small merchants
Still free
Up to ₹1L/month via UPI QR
GST on the fee
18%
On the MDR itself
  • NPCI says running UPI costs ~₹20,000 Cr/year and wants a durable funding model instead of yearly govt subsidy.
  • Revenue split: issuer bank 40% · acquiring bank 30% · UPI app 20% · partner bank 10%. This is bank/fintech revenue, not a government tax.
  • Estimated pool: Goldman Sachs ₹20,600 Cr, Citi ₹16-17k Cr, UBS ₹10-15k Cr. Roundup range: ₹15,000-20,600 Cr/year.
  • Government's actual cut: just the 18% GST on that pool, roughly ₹2,700-3,700 Cr/year.
Sources: Al Jazeera & Business Standard (Sep 2026) · The Hawk/IANS · Entrepreneur India · PickMyWork.
🧾 What a Taxpayer Actually Pays, FY25-26
TaxRateRecent change
Income tax (new)0% to ₹12L, then 5-30%Rebate raised to ₹12L, Budget 2025
Income tax (old)Up to 30% + exemptionsNow a minority choice
Health/Ed Cess4% of tax dueSince 2018
GST5/12/18/28% slabsRationalised, 2025
LTCG (equity)12.5%, above ₹1.25L/yrUp from 10%, Budget 2024
STCG (equity)20%Up from 15%, Budget 2024
STTUp on F&O since Oct '24Collections: ₹8.3k Cr → ₹50,279 Cr (FY26)
Fuel excise+VAT~50-55% of pump price2020 hike never reversed
Professional taxUp to ₹2,500/yrState levy, unchanged
TCS, foreign spend20% above ₹10L/yrThreshold raised, Budget 2025
Sources: CBDT FY25-26 data · Union Budgets 2024-25 & 2025-26 · Zerodha Varsity · Basis Point Insight.
🧮 Calculate Your Own Numbers

Enter your own salary and household spend to see your real income tax (new regime, FY 2025-26, exact slab math), your take-home, and how much tax is hiding inside your everyday spending. The budget numbers below are pre-filled with reasonable Delhi estimates that scale automatically with your income and number of kids, edit any of them.

Annual gross salary (₹)
School-going kids
Monthly spend₹/monthTax rateHidden tax
How this is built: income tax uses the exact FY 2025-26 new-regime slabs (0% to 4L, 5% to 8L, 10% to 12L, 15% to 16L, 20% to 20L, 25% to 24L, 30% above) plus the Section 87A rebate (zero tax if taxable income ≤ ₹12L) and 4% cess. EPF is assumed at 12% of basic pay (basic assumed at 40% of gross), a simplification, actual structures vary by employer. Category tax rates (rent/school exempt, groceries ~3%, fuel ~52% excise+VAT, GST-rated categories at 18% etc.) reflect current law; the rupee amounts are editable estimates, not government data.
📈 10-Year Trend: Up, Not Down
Verified years only, no interpolation:
► Direct tax/GDP: 5.62% (FY14) → 5.97% (FY22) → 6.73% (FY25)
► Overall tax/GDP: 11.1% (FY23) → 11.7% (FY25) → 11.2% (FY27 budget estimate)
► Gross direct-tax collection: ₹7.22L Cr (FY14) → ₹27.03L Cr (FY25), 3.7 times in 11 years
► Net direct tax, FY26: ₹23.40L Cr, up 5.1%; personal tax flat for the first time in years after the ₹12L rebate
► Income tax collected grew 3.5× since FY17 while filers grew 1.9×, see the Tax Terrorism tab
Bottom line: a bigger slice of a bigger economy than in 2014.
Sources: CBDT Income Tax Department Time Series Data FY 2000-01 to 2024-25 · CBDT/Pr. CCA provisional FY 2025-26 collections (May 2026) · Union Budget 2026-27 (PIB) · Business Standard · ClearTax.
🕰 Every New Tax, Cess & Levy Since 2015 — and Who It Hits

A decade of Finance Bills, one row each. Covers income tax, cesses, GST, capital-markets levies, TDS/TCS and digital charges — the wins for the middle class as well as the hits, so you can see the net direction for yourself.

YearTax / LevyWhat changedHits the middle class as
2015Swachh Bharat Cess0.5% added on (almost) all taxable services, service tax effectively 14%→14.5%A little more on every phone bill, restaurant tab, salon visit↑
2016Krishi Kalyan CessAnother 0.5% on services, taking the effective rate to 15%Stacked on top of Swachh Bharat, same everyday bills↑
2016Infrastructure Cess1-4% added on new car purchases, by engine/body typeAnyone buying a new car pays more upfront↑
2017GST launchReplaces excise, VAT, service tax & assorted cesses with one tax; standard services rate lands at 18%, up from ~15%Simpler paperwork, but many everyday services got costlier↕
2018Health & Education CessRaised from 3% to 4% of income tax payable, replacing the old cessExtra cess on every salaried taxpayer's bill, every year since↑
2018LTCG on equity10% tax reintroduced on stock/equity-fund gains above ₹1L/year, no indexationHits mutual-fund SIP and stock investors directly↑
2018GST on insurance premiums18% GST applied on life & health insurance premiums (in force since 2017, widely felt from here)Insurance became a visibly taxed expense, not a tax-free necessity↑
2019TDS on cash withdrawal2% TDS on cash withdrawals above ₹1 Cr/year from a bank account (later slabs widened)Mostly businesses and heavy cash users, limited direct middle-class hit↕
2020Dividend Distribution Tax abolishedCompanies stop paying DDT; dividends now taxed in the investor's hands at slab rateRelief for small investors in a low slab, extra burden for those in 20-30% slabs↕
2020Fuel excise dutyHiked ~₹13/L on petrol and ~₹16/L on diesel amid the pandemic; never fully rolled backDirect hit on every commute, cab ride and delivery charge since↑
2021EPF/VPF interest taxInterest on employee PF contributions above ₹2.5L/year (₹5L for govt staff) made taxableHigher earners and voluntary-PF savers lose a tax-free retirement cushion↑
2022Crypto / VDA taxFlat 30% tax + 4% cess on crypto/NFT gains, plus 1% TCS on transfers; losses can't offset other incomeFalls on young, first-time retail investors in digital assets↑
2023Foreign remittance/travel TCSTCS on foreign remittances & travel packages raised to 20% above ₹7L/year (education/medical stay lower)Families funding foreign education, travel or remittances feel a cash-flow hit (adjustable against final tax)↑
2024Capital-gains & STT hikeLTCG 10%→12.5%, STCG 15%→20% on equity; STT on F&O trades raised sharplyEvery SIP investor and stock-market trader pays more on gains↑
2025New-regime rebateIncome up to ₹12L/year made effectively tax-free under the new regimeDirect, meaningful relief for salaried middle-class filers↓
2025GST 2.0 & insurance exemptionRate slabs rationalised; GST on individual life & health insurance premiums cut from 18% to 0%Cheaper insurance and several everyday goods, after 8 years of paying GST on both↓
2026UPI merchant MDR0.4% MDR reintroduced on UPI payments above ₹2,000; billed to merchants, not shoppers, by ruleMerchants may pass some of this through in prices over time↑
Sources: Union Budget speeches & Finance Acts, 2015-2026 (PIB) · GST Council press releases · CBDT circulars · ClearTax & Zerodha Varsity explainers · Business Standard, Livemint & Reuters coverage · Lok Sabha Q.3645 (2025) · NPCI.
🏛 UPI's Charge vs. the Government's Real Tax Take
Total tax target, FY27
₹44.04L Cr
Union Budget 2026-27 (gross)
UPI MDR pool (private)
₹15-20.6k Cr
~0.05% of the tax target
Govt's actual cut (GST)
₹2.7-3.7k Cr
18% of the MDR pool
The honest picture: UPI's MDR is a private fee between merchants and banks, not a tax, it doesn't hit the government's treasury the way income tax or GST does. The real story is that direct taxes have grown faster than GDP for a decade, regardless of UPI.
The other side: zero-MDR cost the payments industry an est. ₹1,800 Cr in 2020 alone. Industry argues a merchant-funded fee (still free for 95%+ of transactions) is a sustainability fix, not a tax on the public.
Sources: Union Budget 2026-27 (PIB, gross tax revenue ₹44.04L Cr) · News Arena India · Business Standard · Payments Council of India.
📰 Who Actually Wins From the UPI Fee

A Reuters analysis published on 22 September argues the new fee will mostly reward the two apps that already dominate UPI, PhonePe and Google Pay, and widen their lead over everyone else. Here is what the report found, drawn so it's quick to read.

Two apps already handle most of UPI's money
Share of UPI payment value, August 2026
Walmart-backed PhonePe and Google Pay, combinedEvery other UPI app (Paytm, MobiKwik, bank apps…)
Reuters reports only the combined 80% figure, so the two aren't split here. For scale, MobiKwik ranks 15th among UPI apps by number of payments.
So most of the new fee money flows to them too
Bernstein's estimate of yearly fee revenue for payment apps by March 2028 (₹ at ~₹95/$)
All payment apps
$1.1 bn
~₹10,500 Cr
PhonePe + Google Pay
~$900 M
~₹8,500 Cr
Everyone else
~$200 M
~₹1,900 Cr
"Everyone else" is the difference between Bernstein's two figures, worked out by IndiaWatch. Note that Bernstein's app-revenue estimate is higher than the "20% to the UPI app" split quoted earlier on this page would suggest; brokerages are using different assumptions and different years, so treat all of these as estimates, not accounts.
India's fee is still cheaper than its peers
Merchant fee on instant-payment systems, % of the payment
India UPI (from 15 Oct)
0.4%
China Alipay, Singapore PayNow, Brazil Pix
0.6–1.5%
0%0.5%1.0%1.5%
Reuters gives one range for the three systems together, so it's drawn as a band rather than three separate bars. UPI above ₹2,000 also carries 18% GST on the fee.
What a shop pays on one payment
Drag to pick a bill amount. The shop pays this, not you, at least on paper.
₹5,000
Rules: 0.4% on payments above ₹2,000, capped at ₹300; 18% GST on top of the fee. Small merchants taking under ₹1L a month by UPI QR, and transfers between people, stay free.
Who gains, who adapts, who pays
What the Reuters report says each group is likely to do
PhonePe & Google Pay
Biggest winners

Industry sources say the new income makes it worth pushing into rural India, where payments are small but the data helps sell loans and other products.

Smaller apps
Chasing bigger bills

Expected to go after higher-value payments like tickets, business payments and utility bills, and to offer more credit. MobiKwik's co-founder welcomed the fee; a Blume Ventures investor said most of the gains will still go to the two leaders.

Merchants
Mostly absorbing it

They can't add the fee to a bill openly, but executives expect some quiet price creep. A Mumbai clothing store manager, with about 80% of sales on UPI, said he won't pass it on.

Shoppers
Not going back to cash

The RBI, Bernstein, executives and the Mumbai shopkeepers Reuters spoke to all expect little shift back to cash. One shopper said he's fine as long as the fee doesn't keep rising.

The question regulators keep dodging: NPCI, which runs UPI, has a plan to stop any single app from handling more than 30% of UPI payments. It has put that decision off twice. With the fee giving the top two apps more money to grow, Reuters says the cap and how much concentration regulators will tolerate are likely to come back into focus.
The other side: PhonePe says the fee helps cover real running costs that the free model never paid for, and smaller players say it finally gives them a business reason to keep investing in UPI. Supporters also point out 0.4% is below what Alipay, PayNow and Pix charge.
📊 Live Fuel Price & INR Tracker (continued from Economy)
🔴 TODAY · N/A
Petrol ₹/L · Diesel ₹/L in Delhi · USD/INR ₹ · Brent ~$/bbl
Brent above $102/bbl (3 Oct) as Saudi Arabia weighs an offensive against the Houthis · pump prices unchanged on 3 Oct · state refiners absorbing the gap, ICRA warns of squeeze
💲 INR Exchange Rate Tracker ·
₹ per 1 unit of foreign currency · Fetching live rates… ·
▼ USD/INR hit record ₹97.15 on May 19, 2026
USD 🇺🇸
₹…
Loading…
EUR 🇪🇺
₹…
Loading…
GBP 🇬🇧
₹…
Loading…
JPY 🇯🇵 ×100
₹…
Loading…
AED 🇦🇪
₹…
Loading…
SAR 🇸🇦
₹…
Loading…
CNY 🇨🇳
₹…
Loading…
PKR 🇵🇰 ×100
₹…
Loading…
► View all currencies (14 currencies)
CurrencyCode₹ Value (live)UnitKey Driver
Loading live rates…
Why is INR at record lows (₹95.9/$)?
US-Iran conflict drove Brent above $90+, swelling India's oil import bill (85% crude imported). FII outflows of ₹60,000+ crore in May 2026 added pressure. RBI sold dollars aggressively, forex reserves fell from $700B to ~$665B in 3 weeks. USD/INR peaked at ₹96.97 on May 19 to 20, the worst level in history.
🛢 Fuel vs Crude Oil
Crude Oil vs Retail Fuel Prices in India · Live Tracker
Brent Crude converted to ₹/litre (raw refinery-gate cost using historical USD/INR) vs Delhi Petrol Retail Price (₹/litre) · Same currency & volume · Jan 2020, Today
Fetching live price…
Brent Crude (Live, ₹/L)
N/A
Loading…
Delhi Petrol
₹102.12
Delhi · 3 Oct 2026
Delhi Diesel
₹95.20
Delhi · 3 Oct 2026
Tax in Petrol Price
~55%
Excise + VAT floor
Crude vs Retail Price
Price Breakdown per Litre
🛢 Crude: N/A 🏭 Refining: N/A 📋 Excise: ₹19.90 🏛 VAT: N/A 🤝 Dealer: ₹3.86 📊 Tax%: N/A
Why don't retail prices fall when crude falls?

► Excise + VAT = ~55% of petrol price creates a price floor, any fall in crude is absorbed by OMC margins, not passed to consumers.

► Iran War 2026 spike: Brent hit $90+ in May; 4 hikes in 2 weeks added ~₹8/L on petrol, ₹7/L on diesel.

► Covid excise grab (2020): Centre hiked excise by ₹13/L when crude was $19/bbl. Never reversed.

Bottom Line: India's fuel price is a political instrument, not a market price.
🧾 Tax Terrorism
Who actually carries India's income tax, FY 2016-17 to FY 2025-26
3.5×
Growth in income tax collected, FY17 to FY25
1.9×
Growth in people filing returns
~2.8 Cr
Filers who owed any tax, FY25
~2%
Share of Indians who pay income tax

If the number of taxpayers grew less than 2 times, how did income tax collection grow 3.5 times?

This tab answers that with the government's own numbers, then gives the government's side of the argument.
📏 The Gap, FY 2016-17 to FY 2024-25
Income tax collectedNet non-corporate tax, ₹3.50L Cr → ₹12.35L Cr
3.53×
Tax deducted at sourceAll direct taxes, ₹3.43L Cr → ₹9.48L Cr
2.76×
Size of the economyNominal GDP, ₹153.6L Cr → ₹330.7L Cr
2.15×
People filing returnsUnique filers, 4.47 Cr → 8.56 Cr
1.92×
The short answer: collections grew because India's incomes grew, because more of every rupee is now taxed at source, and because the tax is being collected from a small and shrinking group. Between FY20 and FY25, collections rose 2.5 times while the number of filers who owed any tax fell from about 3.6 crore to about 2.8 crore. The average bill for each of those payers went from about ₹1.4 lakh to about ₹4.4 lakh.
How this is built: "income tax collected" is CBDT's net non-corporate tax, which covers individuals, HUFs, firms and other non-company taxpayers and includes securities transaction tax. TDS covers all direct taxes, including companies. GDP is at current prices (MoSPI). Multiples are IndiaWatch calculations from those official figures.
📊 Year by Year: Filers, Payers and the Bill
Year People filing Zero tax due Owed tax Share who owe Net collection Per paying filer
2016-174.47 Crnot disclosedn/an/a₹3.50L Crn/a
2017-185.45 Crnot disclosedn/an/a₹4.20L Crn/a
2018-196.33 Crnot disclosedn/an/a₹4.73L Crn/a
2019-206.49 Cr2.90 Cr~3.6 Cr~55%₹4.93L Cr~₹1.4 lakh
2020-216.72 Cr4.84 Cr~1.9 Cr~28%₹4.88L Cr~₹2.6 lakh
2021-226.96 Cr5.05 Cr~1.9 Cr~27%₹6.97L Cr~₹3.7 lakh
2022-237.40 Cr5.16 Cr~2.2 Cr~30%₹8.33L Cr~₹3.7 lakh
2023-248.09 Cr~5.50 Cr~2.6 Cr~32%₹10.45L Cr~₹4.0 lakh
2024-258.56 Cr5.58 Cr*~2.8 Cr*~33.5%*₹12.35L Cr~₹4.4 lakh
2025-26awaitedawaitedawaitedawaited₹13.72L Cr gross†awaited
  • * FY25 zero-tax count is the government's snapshot as of 31 Dec 2024, when 8.39 crore had filed; the share is taken from that snapshot.
  • † FY26 figure is gross (before refunds) non-corporate tax. It was flat against ₹13.74L Cr in FY25, the first year of the ₹12 lakh rebate.
  • "Owed tax" and "per paying filer" are IndiaWatch calculations: filers minus zero-tax filers, and collection divided by that number. The per-payer figure overstates the real bill per person, because collections also include firms, STT and TDS from people who never file.
📉 More Tax, Fewer People Paying It
Sources: CBDT, Income Tax Department Time Series Data FY 2000-01 to 2024-25 (tables 1.1, 1.4, 1.5, 1.8) · Lok Sabha & Rajya Sabha written replies by MoS Finance Pankaj Chaudhary (Jul 2023, Dec 2023, Dec 2024, Feb 2025) · Business Standard, Deccan Herald, SAG Infotech coverage of those replies · CBDT/Pr. CCA provisional FY 2025-26 collections via Juris Hour & Business Standard (May 2026).
🔍 So How Did 1.9× the People Pay 3.5× the Tax?

Incomes grew, and the slabs didn't keep up

The economy more than doubled in rupee terms, so salaries and profits did too. Under the old regime, the ₹2.5 lakh basic exemption stayed frozen from 2014, so inflation alone pushed people into higher slabs every year without any law changing. This is the biggest single reason, and it isn't unique to India.

The rebate shrank the paying pool, not the bill

Each rebate increase (₹5 lakh in 2019, ₹7 lakh in 2023, ₹12 lakh in 2025) moved millions of lower earners to zero tax. That is real relief for them. But the rest of the collection now comes from a smaller group of higher earners, who pay 15-30% slab rates plus surcharge and the 4% cess. Part of the jump in "tax per payer" is this reshuffling: the people who paid small amounts left the pool.

Investors pay more than before

Long-term gains on shares, tax-free until 2018, are now taxed at 12.5%. Short-term gains went from 15% to 20% in 2024. STT on futures and options was raised sharply, and STT alone brought in ₹57,522 crore gross in FY26. The retail trading boom since 2020 means crores of new investors now pay these taxes, and all of it is counted in the same bucket as income tax.

More tax is taken before you see your money

TDS across all direct taxes rose 2.76 times, faster than the economy. The TDS and TCS net now covers salaries, interest, rent, property purchases, cash withdrawals, foreign remittances and e-commerce sales. For a salaried person, the tax is gone before the salary arrives, so there is nothing left to hide even if one wanted to.

A handful of cities carry it

By taxpayer address, Maharashtra alone accounted for ₹8.97 lakh crore of the ₹22.26 lakh crore collected in FY25 (all direct taxes, including companies). Maharashtra, Karnataka, Delhi, Tamil Nadu and Gujarat together gave about 73%.

The phrase itself: "tax terrorism" was the BJP's own charge against the UPA government in 2014, aimed at retrospective taxation and aggressive demands on companies like Vodafone. Arun Jaitley argued then that when a government fails to widen the tax net, it ends up squeezing the people already in it. In 2020 the Prime Minister said India had moved from tax terrorism to tax transparency. The numbers above show the net did widen for filers, but not for payers.
⚖ The Government's Side
  • Relief is real. The ₹12 lakh rebate in Budget 2025 cost about ₹1 lakh crore a year. Gross non-corporate tax was flat in FY26 and income tax came in ₹1.26 lakh crore below the budget target, which is what a genuine tax cut looks like.
  • Better compliance isn't higher tax. The government says TDS, the Annual Information Statement and data matching caught income that used to go unreported. On this view, the same rates are simply being paid more honestly.
  • Zero-tax filers aren't free riders. Many file only to claim refunds of TDS already cut, and everyone pays GST, fuel taxes and other indirect taxes on what they buy.
  • The mix changed on purpose. The 2019 corporate tax cut lowered company taxes, so personal tax overtook corporate tax in FY23. Supporters say that was meant to boost investment, not to shift the load onto households.
  • Most rates came down. The new regime has lower slab rates and a lower top surcharge (25% instead of 37%) than before.
What to watch next: Budget 2026-27 expects personal income tax of ₹14.66 lakh crore, 11.7% more than FY26's revised ₹13.12 lakh crore. If that growth comes back after one flat year, the pattern above returns with it. The FY26 data on how many filers owed tax, due in Parliament's winter session, will show whether the paying pool shrank again under the ₹12 lakh rebate.
Sources: PRS Legislative Research, Union Budget 2026-27 Analysis · PIB, Summary of Union Budget 2026-27 · Business Standard (15 Aug 2018, "Tax terrorism is thriving") · Quartz (Apr 2015, Jaitley on tax terrorism) · Journals of India (Nov 2020, PM's "tax terrorism to tax transparency") · Deccan Herald (Vodafone & retrospective tax) · CBDT time series (state-wise collections, table 1.2).
✊ The Right to Dissent LIVE
Jantar Mantar · hunger strikes · protest history under this government · how each was met
26 days
Wangchuk's NEET hunger strike, ended 23 Jul, no force used
3
Rounds of govt–CJP talks before Pradhan quit
Resigned
Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan, 25 Jul 2026
Sept 23–24
Wangchuk's new Ladakh padyatra & Martyrs' Day, live now
The Government That Cannot Hear, Until It Has To

India's only sanctioned protest square sits a few hundred metres from Parliament. This tab tracks who has stood on it, what they asked for, and how the state has tended to respond: silence and delay for weeks, then a late concession once a movement becomes too large or too visible to ignore. The one clear exception is the farmers' movement of 2020–21; the NEET protests of 2026 turned out to be a second.

🔴 Current status · updated 3 Oct 2026

Jantar Mantar was sealed on Gandhi Jayanti. On 2 October 2026 Delhi Police detained more than 500 people trying to reach the square for a rally seeking the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, among them AAP leaders Atishi, Saurabh Bharadwaj and Sanjay Singh and activists from AISA, SFI and DYFI. Police said no permission had been granted and prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the BNSS were in force across New Delhi district; 12 metro stations were closed and mobile internet was suspended around the site. Amnesty International said the response trampled the right to peaceful assembly. In Mumbai, where police said a 2013 Bombay High Court order left them unable to permit a gathering at Shivaji Park, the CJP rallied anyway and announced a march to Jantar Mantar on 10 October. The background is in the Election Watch tab.

The NEET demand was met. Sonam Wangchuk fasted for 26 days from 28 June to 23 July 2026 at Jantar Mantar in support of the Gen-Z led Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), which was demanding the resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan over the NEET-UG 2026 paper leak. He ended the fast on his own on 23 July after the government gave assurances; there was no forcible removal or hospitalisation, correcting an earlier, inaccurate version of this page. Two days later, on 25 July, after three rounds of talks between ministers (JP Nadda, Jitendra Singh) and CJP representatives, Pradhan resigned, and the government agreed to CJP's other two demands: dropping FIRs against protesters and compensating NEET-leak victims' families. Pralhad Joshi was given additional charge of the Education Ministry the next day.

A separate, older demand is live right now. Wangchuk's underlying cause has long been Ladakh statehood and Sixth Schedule constitutional safeguards, the issue that led to his detention under the National Security Act on 26 September 2025, two days after protests that left 4 dead and dozens injured in Leh; he was released on 14 March 2026 after about six months in custody. Talks between the Leh Apex Body / Kargil Democratic Alliance and a Home Ministry sub-committee on 9 September 2026 produced, in Wangchuk's words, "hardly anything new." He initially threatened a padyatra from 19–24 September, then scaled it down on 17 September, citing cold weather. The symbolic 20 km march went ahead on 23 September, ending at the NDS Martyrs' Memorial Park in Leh, where Apex Body and religious leaders including Chering Dorjay Lakrook and Wangchuk addressed the crowd. A "Martyrs' Day" gathering on 24 September marked one year since four people died in last year's unrest; the Leh District Bar Association suspended court work that day in solidarity. Talks with the Centre continue, with a possible new Article 371K reported to be under discussion, but statehood itself remains unresolved. On 27 September, in Delhi to mark a year since his NSA detention, Wangchuk said he wanted to see real progress before Gandhi Jayanti on 2 October, failing which peaceful protests would resume. IndiaWatch had found no announcement of a fresh programme as of 3 October.

Sources: Wikipedia (Sonam Wangchuk; Dharmendra Pradhan; 2026 Delhi Jantar Mantar protests) · Khaleej Times & WION (25–26 Jul 2026, Pradhan resignation & Joshi appointment) · Aaj English TV (25 Jul 2026, talks & CJP demands) · India TV News & Business Today (10–13 Sept 2026, Ladakh padyatra threat) · Free Press Journal (18 Sept 2026, padyatra scaled down to 23–24 Sept) · Daily Excelsior (Sept 2026, padyatra ends at NDS Martyrs' Memorial Park; Leh Bar suspends work on 24 Sept) · Sunday Guardian (Sept 2026, Article 371K talks) · Asian News Channel / PTI (NSA detention & release timeline) · The News Mill / ANI (27 Sept 2026, 2 Oct deadline) · Outlook India, Al Jazeera, Amnesty International (2 Oct 2026, Jantar Mantar detentions).
🕰 A Decade of Dissent, and the Standard Reply

Every movement below reached the capital. Independent reporting and the protesters' own accounts describe a recurring state response: outlast, contain, or relocate, rather than negotiate. The year-long farmers' movement is the one clear exception, and even it began with denial and barricades before the laws were repealed.

Movement Year What They Asked How It Was Met Outcome
Anti-CAA / Shaheen Bagh 2019 to 20 Withdrawal of CAA-NRC; the sit-in was led largely by women. Police action, internet shutdowns and a prolonged refusal to engage with the core demand; sites cleared under the COVID lockdown. Cleared · No talks
Farmers' movement 2020 to 21 Repeal of three farm laws. Denied Jantar Mantar and Ramlila; pushed to the Singhu / Tikri / Ghazipur borders. Barricades, trenches, internet cuts; movement branded as "infiltrated." Laws repealed
Wrestlers' protest 2023 Arrest of WFI chief & BJP MP Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh over sexual-harassment allegations. 35-day sit-in at Jantar Mantar; Vinesh Phogat, Sakshi Malik & Bajrang Punia detained on 28 May, the day the new Parliament was inaugurated, and the site cleared. Detained · Cleared
Agnipath protests 2022 Rollback of the short-tenure military recruitment scheme. Contained through preventive policing; scheme retained. Contained
Wangchuk, Ladakh statehood 2024 to 25 Statehood and Sixth Schedule safeguards for Ladakh. Refused Jantar Mantar permission and briefly detained; fasted at Ladakh Bhawan instead. A later 35-day fast ended in Sept 2025 after clashes turned violent. Ignored · Called off
CJP / NEET leak (resolved) 2026 Resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan; FIR withdrawals; compensation for NEET-leak victims' families. 35 days of protest and a 26-day hunger strike, followed by three rounds of ministerial talks with CJP representatives. All 3 demands met
Wangchuk, Ladakh statehood (round 2) (current) 2026 Statehood, Sixth Schedule safeguards and an elected Ladakh assembly. 9 Sept MHA sub-committee talks yielded no new draft; padyatra scaled down to a symbolic 20 km march (23 Sept) and Martyrs' Day (24 Sept). Ongoing
Sources: Wikipedia (2020 to 21 farmers' protest; 2023 wrestlers' protest; 2026 Jantar Mantar protests) · Deccan Herald (28 May 2023) · The Week (3 Jun 2023) · Question of Cities (2023) · Outlook Traveller (Jan 2026) · Tribune India · Countercurrents (Jul 2026).
💧 Worshipped in Speeches, Ignored in Life, the Men Who Died for the Ganga

In 2014, Narendra Modi stood on the ghats of Varanasi and declared "Maa Ganga has called me." The river is invoked constantly in political speech, and more than ₹20,000 crore has been badged under the Namami Gange clean-up programme. Yet Prof. G.D. Agarwal, a former IIT Kanpur professor and ex to member-secretary of the Central Pollution Control Board, who as a monk took the name Swami Gyan Swaroop Sanand, wrote to the Prime Minister again and again asking for a real law to protect the river he had spent his life studying. He received no reply. On the 111th day of his fast, 11 October 2018, aged 86, he died at AIIMS Rishikesh, days after being forcibly moved there. The government's acknowledgement came only after his death: the PM tweeted condolences, and the Ganga minister said "almost all his demands" had been accepted. He was not the only one.

Who Fast What They Asked Government Response Outcome
Prof. G.D. Agarwal
Swami Gyan Swaroop Sanand · 86 · IIT Kanpur / ex-CPCB
22 Jun 2018
111 days
A Ganga Protection Act, scrapping of hydro projects on the river and its tributaries, and free-flowing water. Repeated letters to PM Modi went unanswered. Condolences and a claim that "almost all demands" were met came after he died. Died 11 Oct 2018
Sant Gopal Das
ascetic · ~36
24 Jun 2018
100+ days
An end to Ganga riverbed mining and a law to protect the river; took up Agarwal's cause after his death. Moved between hospitals, then "disappeared" from AIIMS Delhi in Dec 2018. Opposition leaders alleged the Centre removed him; his family still has no trace. Whereabouts unknown
Swami Atmabodhanand
engineering dropout, Kerala · 26 · Matri Sadan
24 Oct 2018
194 days
Cancellation of dams on the Bhagirathi & Alaknanda, a ban on mining, and an autonomous Ganga council and law. Letters to the PM again went unanswered. Only after 194 days did the NMCG chief give a verbal assurance on curbing sand mining. Broke fast May 2019
Reverence in rhetoric, silence in practice. The state that names the Ganga its mother could not find a reply for the scientist who was dying to save her, until the reply no longer mattered. A distinguished professor fasted himself to death over 111 days; a second faster vanished from a government hospital; a third had to fast 194 days to win a verbal promise. None of them received the one thing they asked for while they could still use it: to be heard.
For balance, the government's position.
The Centre points to the ₹20,000 crore+ Namami Gange programme, the October 2018 notification mandating a minimum environmental ("e-flow") for the Ganga, and Water Resources Minister Nitin Gadkari's statement that most of Agarwal's demands had been accepted. Officials say activists were hospitalised out of concern for their health. Critics, including Agarwal's own ashram, Matri Sadan, counter that the core demand, a binding Ganga Protection Act, was never enacted, that the responses came only under the pressure of a death, and that Gopal Das's disappearance was never credibly explained.
Sources: The Wire (GD Agarwal's final letter to Modi) · Hindustan Times / PTI (11 to 14 Oct 2018) · Gulf News · Deccan Herald · Down To Earth · DNA India (194-day fast) · Dialogue Earth · SANDRP · India TV.
🚧 The Shrinking Square

Jantar Mantar was never designed as a protest venue, it became one over three decades. Increasingly, permits are granted only for fixed hours (often until 5 p.m.), Section 144 is imposed more readily, and large sit-ins are relocated to Ramlila Maidan, Burari, or out to the city's borders. Activists across movements have used the same phrase for these managed spaces: "echo chambers."

For balance, the government's position.
Authorities and courts have justified restrictions on grounds of law and order, traffic and noise, pollution (the National Green Tribunal has cited environmental limits at Jantar Mantar) and public inconvenience, and note that designated sites like Ramlila Maidan remain available. The Centre also points out that it eventually repealed the farm laws after negotiation, and that police act on the terms of the permits granted. Critics counter that permission delays, time caps and relocation to low-visibility sites function as a way to mute protest without formally banning it. The record above is offered so readers can weigh it themselves.
This tracker documents a pattern, not a verdict. Every row is sourced; where the government's stated rationale exists, it is shown.
🔇 Rights & Repression
🔇 Rights & Repression Tracker LIVE
Press crackdowns · UAPA / sedition abuse · RTI activist killings · Censorship · Opposition targeting · Verified public records
50+
Journalists arrested since 2014
159/180
RSF Press Freedom 2024
65+
RTI activists killed / attacked
7,000+
URLs blocked (IT Act 69A)
0
Convictions in RTI killings
How the BJP Government Systematically Weakened the RTI Act

The Right to Information Act 2005 was the single most powerful accountability tool available to India's 140 crore citizens, a law that let any person demand answers from any public authority within 30 days. In the decade since 2014, the Modi government has not repealed it. Instead it has done something more durable: hollowed it out. Through amendments that weakened watchdogs, exemptions that shielded the most powerful institutions, deliberate vacancies in enforcement bodies, and court victories that insulated key funds from scrutiny, the RTI has been transformed from a sword into a blunt instrument. The PM CARES Fund, created during COVID with ₹10,000+ crore in public donations, is the clearest symbol: constituted to be permanently beyond audit, beyond RTI, and beyond parliamentary oversight, while courts accepted the government's framing that a public trust receiving public money is somehow private.

38 lakh
RTI applications pending at CIC (2024) · avg wait 2 to 4 years
₹10,000+ Cr
PM CARES Fund, public donations, zero RTI, zero CAG audit
0
Cases investigated by Lokpal since appointment in 2019
1,200+
Arrests under Section 66A, a law SC struck down in 2015
📋 What BJP Removed from RTI Purview, Step by Step
Year What Was Done What It Means in Practice What Was Shielded Court Position
2019 RTI Amendment Act 2019, Central govt given power to fix tenure, salary and service conditions of Chief Information Commissioner and all State Information Commissioners by executive order Information Commissioners who adjudicate RTI appeals against the government now serve at the pleasure of the very government they are supposed to hold accountable. Chilling effect on rulings against powerful ministries. Government ministries · PM Office · Cabinet Secretariat SC upheld amendment
2020 PM CARES Fund declared a private trust, ₹10,000+ Cr raised from public, PSUs and foreign donors during COVID; declared exempt from RTI, CAG audit, and parliamentary questions Citizens cannot find out who donated, how money was spent, which ventilator purchases were made, or which contractors were paid. Audited only by a private CA firm chosen by the trust itself, not the CAG. PM CARES Fund · Donor identities · All expenditure · Vendor contracts SC dismissed petition
2018 to 24 Electoral Bonds, RTI rejected at every stage, all RTI applications to SBI and Finance Ministry seeking donor names rejected citing "commercial confidence" and "national security" RTI mechanism completely failed citizens on the single biggest political finance question. Disclosure came only via SC writ petition in Feb 2024, not through RTI. RTI can be nullified by executive refusal when courts don't intervene. ₹20,000+ Cr in political donations · SBI records · Finance Ministry files SC forced disclosure 2024
2019 Political parties exempted from RTI, CIC ruled in 2013 that BJP, INC and 4 other parties are "public authorities." Modi govt proposed retrospective amendment to exempt parties. Neither BJP nor INC has ever complied. Citizens cannot RTI any political party about funding, internal decisions, or asset declarations. Both parties defied the CIC ruling for over a decade. SC has not enforced compliance. All political party funding · Internal decisions · Candidate selection SC not enforced
2014 to present Whistleblower Protection Act 2014, rules never notified, Parliament passed the Act to protect RTI applicants exposing corruption. Ten years later, rules needed to operationalise it have never been issued. Act exists on paper but cannot be invoked. RTI activists continue to be killed, 65+ since 2005, with near-total impunity. No killer has been convicted under this Act. All whistleblowers · RTI activists · Public servants exposing corruption No challenge filed
2019 to present Lokpal, appointed 6 years late, then made toothless, Lokpal Act 2013 mandated an independent ombudsman to investigate PM and ministers. Appointed 2019 but has no independent prosecution wing and has investigated zero cases as of 2026. First Lokpal was Justice P.C. Ghose, appointed 1 month after retirement, having sat on the Rafale bench that dismissed probe petitions. Thousands of complaints received; none investigated. Accountability theatre. PM Office · Cabinet ministers · Senior bureaucrats · CBI Director No judicial review
2023 DPDP Act 2023, new blanket privacy exemption, Section 44(3) amended RTI to remove the public interest override for personal information. Governments can now refuse RTI requests citing data privacy even for public servants' official acts. Activists used this provision to obtain salary details, assets of officials, and procurement records. The DPDP amendment creates a new blanket exemption that did not exist in the original RTI Act. Officials' asset declarations · Salary disclosures · Procurement beneficiaries HC challenge pending
🔒 PM CARES Fund, Why It Cannot Be Audited & Why Courts Agreed
PM CARES Fund, Public Money, Private Trust, Zero Accountability
Set up: 28 March 2020  ·  Amount raised: ₹10,000+ Cr (declared)  ·  CAG audit: None  ·  RTI: Not applicable  ·  Parliamentary oversight: None
Why Govt Says It's Beyond RTI & CAG
  • ▸Registered as a public charitable trust, not a government fund. Only bodies created by law (like PMNRF) are auditable by CAG under the CAG Act 1971. PM CARES was created by a trust deed, not an Act of Parliament.
  • ▸Not a "public authority" under RTI s.2(h), RTI covers bodies "established by or under the Constitution" or "by law." Govt argued PM CARES was created by executive order as a private trust, placing it outside this definition.
  • ▸"Voluntary donations" argument, PSU contributions were "voluntary," not mandatory state spending. If no government money was compulsorily transferred, the CAG's mandate doesn't formally apply, even if every PSU in India donated under implicit government pressure.
  • ▸Private auditor self-appointed, Trust deed names a private CA firm as auditor. Government said an independent audit was already happening, making CAG redundant, though the private auditor's report is not publicly available in full detail.
Why Courts Accepted This & What Critics Say
  • ▸SC dismissed petition (June 2021), The court declined to order a CAG audit, holding PM CARES is a "public charitable trust" and petitioners had not shown specific misuse. A circular standard: you cannot show misuse when the fund is designed to prevent evidence from emerging.
  • ▸Technical reading over public interest, Courts applied a narrow textual reading of the CAG Act. Former CAG officers have noted the CAG has historically audited bodies that are not strictly "government funds" if they receive substantial public money, the precedent existed but was not applied here.
  • ▸PM as trustee, conflict ignored, The PM is the ex-officio Chairman of the trust. A structural conflict of interest: the person who decides what the fund spends on is also the person being protected from audit. Courts did not engage substantively with this.
  • ▸What remains unknown, Which companies supplied ventilators amid quality fraud reports? What was paid for PPE kits? How were allocations split between states? All unanswered. The PMNRF, which predates Modi, is subject to CAG audit and RTI. PM CARES was structured specifically to avoid both.
Sources: SC order in Samyak Gangwal v. UoI (June 2021)  ·  CAG Act 1971  ·  RTI Act 2005 s.2(h)  ·  Finance Ministry RTI rejection orders  ·  The Wire  ·  Indian Express  ·  PUCL  ·  Internet Freedom Foundation
Resolved Updated 20 Sept 2026

Education Minister Resigns After Hunger Strike and Weeks of NEET Protest — Correcting an Earlier Version of This Page

Sonam Wangchuk fasted for 26 days (28 June–23 July 2026) at Jantar Mantar backing the Gen-Z led Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), which demanded Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation over the NEET-UG 2026 paper leak. He ended the fast on his own on 23 July after government assurances; he was not forcibly removed or hospitalised by police, correcting an earlier version of this page that reported that. On 25 July, after three rounds of talks between ministers and CJP representatives, Pradhan resigned and Pralhad Joshi took additional charge of the ministry the next day. The government also agreed to drop FIRs against protesters and compensate NEET-leak victims' families.

🔍 What happened

Sonam Wangchuk's NEET Hunger Strike: How It Ended

Days Fasting
26
28 Jun–23 Jul
Students Affected
~22.7L
Re-examined, NEET leak
Outcome
Jul 25
Pradhan resigned
The demand, and what was granted:
Resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan; dropped FIRs against protesters; compensation for NEET-leak victims' families. All three were conceded.
Timeline:
Jun 28: Hunger strike begins at Jantar Mantar
Jul 23: Wangchuk ends his 26-day fast after government assurances
Jul 25: After three rounds of talks, Dharmendra Pradhan resigns as Education Minister
Jul 26: Pralhad Joshi given additional charge of the Education Ministry
Sept 9–18: Wangchuk's separate Ladakh statehood demand resurfaces; see the Right to Dissent tab for the current status

What changed from our earlier reporting: An earlier version of this page said Wangchuk was forcibly removed from Jantar Mantar and hospitalised by police on 18 July. That was inaccurate. He continued his fast for five more days and ended it voluntarily on 23 July, once the government gave assurances.

Sources: Wikipedia (Sonam Wangchuk; Dharmendra Pradhan), Khaleej Times & WION (25–26 Jul 2026), Aaj English TV (25 Jul 2026)

Journalist / Outlet State What Triggered Arrest / Action Law Year Days Held Status
Sources: Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) · Reporters Without Borders (RSF) · Press Council of India · LiveLaw · The Wire · Bar & Bench · SC orders
UAPA conviction rate: 2.8% (NCRB 2023). Average trial: 9+ years. The state uses denial of bail as punishment, this tracks people jailed for speech and dissent, not violence.
Accused Who They Are What They Said / Did Law Arrested Days Jailed Status
Sources: NCRB · SC orders · HC bail judgments · The Wire · Scroll.in · Amnesty International · Human Rights Watch
Pattern: RTI activists who filed applications exposing local corruption, ration fraud, illegal mining, contractor cartels, were subsequently killed or attacked. In almost every case: no conviction. This is corruption silencing its own auditors.
Activist State RTI Filed Against (What Corruption) Incident Year Conviction
Sources: RTI Foundation of India · Satark Nagrik Sangathan · NCPRI · CHRI · The Hindu · NDTV
ADR India 2024: 95% of ED political cases since 2014 target opposition politicians. Of 25 politicians who switched to BJP after facing ED/CBI cases, 23 saw cases go cold within 12 months of switching.
Politician Party Position Allegation Agency Filed Outcome
Sources: ED press releases · CBI · ADR India · Association for Democratic Reforms · LiveLaw · SC orders
India is the world's #1 requester of content takedowns from Twitter/X and Google (Google Transparency Report 2024). IT Act Section 69A blocks require no judicial review, a single bureaucrat can order a site blocked.
What Was Blocked / Censored Type Stated Reason What It Actually Covered Year Status
Sources: IT Act 69A orders (RTI) · Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) · SFLC.in · SC orders · The Wire · Medianama · Access Now
The RTI Act 2005 was the landmark achievement of the Anna Hazare-led civil society movement, giving every citizen the right to demand information from any public authority within 30 days. Two decades later, the Modi government has systematically hollowed it out, exempting key bodies, delaying appointments, and burying requests in arrears.
What Was Promised / What the Law Said What the BJP Govt Did Instead Year Status
PM CARES Fund: Full transparency. All public funds must be disclosable under RTI. The PM CARES Fund was set up to receive public donations during COVID-19. Declared a private trust, exempt from RTI. Over ₹10,000 Cr in public donations received; CAG audit refused; donor list not disclosed. SC dismissed petition seeking RTI applicability. 2020 RTI Exempted
Chief Information Commissioners: RTI Act requires CIC and State ICs to be appointed promptly, with security of tenure equivalent to Election Commissioners. RTI Amendment Act 2019: Govt unilaterally changed tenure and salary of Information Commissioners, making them dependent on govt goodwill. SC and civil society called it an attack on RTI's independence. 2019 Law Diluted
30-day response guarantee: Every public authority must respond within 30 days. Penalty of ₹250/day for delay up to ₹25,000. 38 lakh RTI applications pending as of 2024 (CIC data). Average wait time: 2 to 4 years at Central Information Commission. Many RTI replies are evasive one-liners. Penalty almost never imposed on defaulting officers. 2024 Backlog: 38L cases
Political party transparency: CIC ruled in 2013 that BJP, Congress, CPM, BSP, NCP and INC are "public authorities" under RTI Act and must disclose funding and decisions. Both BJP and Congress refused to comply. Modi govt proposed RTI Amendment to retrospectively exempt political parties. Even after SC orders, no party has disclosed funding sources under RTI. 2013 to present Parties Exempt, Defied SC
Electoral bonds transparency: RTI applications filed seeking donor names from SBI and Finance Ministry. All RTI applications rejected citing "commercial confidence" and "national security." SC eventually forced disclosure in Feb 2024, not through RTI but through writ petition. RTI mechanism had completely failed. 2018 to 2024 RTI Rejected, SC forced disclosure
Anna Hazare movement promise (2011): Jan Lokpal Bill, independent ombudsman with power to investigate PM, CBI, judiciary. Hazare's fast forced UPA govt to pass Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act 2013. Lokpal appointed only in 2019, 6 years after the law. Zero cases investigated by Lokpal as of 2026. No prosecution initiated. First Lokpal (Justice P.C. Ghose) was a retired SC judge who had been on the Rafale bench that dismissed probe petitions, appointed within 1 month of retirement. Lokpal has no independent prosecution wing. 2013 to 2026 0 cases investigated
Whistleblower Protection Act 2014: Passed to protect RTI activists and public servants who expose corruption from harassment and retaliation. Rules never notified, Act remains inoperative 10+ years after passage. Not a single RTI activist murder has been prosecuted under this Act. Activists continue to be killed with near-total impunity (see RTI Activists tab). 2014 to present Rules Never Notified
Sources: Central Information Commission annual reports · RTI Foundation of India · Satark Nagrik Sangathan · SC orders · Amnesty International · The Wire · Indian Express · ADR India
🚫 Government Scheme Fraud, By ScaleLIVE
Ministry-level · CAG / CBI / ED / SC verified · Current minister responsible · 2024 to 26
₹3.6L Cr+
Fraud tracked
14
Schemes flagged
0
Ministers charged
# Scheme / Case Ministry Current Minister Amount at Risk Agency Source / Authority Govt Action Status
● Red border = evidence shielded  |  ● Amber = audit notice, no prosecution  |  ● Green = meaningful action  |  Sources: CAG India · CBI · ED · SC orders · Parliamentary committees · RTI
🏛 MINISTERS CURRENTLY IN OFFICE · ACTIVE CORRUPTION CASES & INVESTIGATIONS
Showing: Sources: ED · CBI · SC orders · RTI · verified press releases
Name Current / Recent Post Corruption Charge Agency Source / Case Ref Status
📰 Significant Cases & Investigations · 2025 to 26
8
Active cases
₹15,000+ Cr
Tracked this tab
Case Ministry / Dept Amount Agency Action taken Status Date
Sources: CAG India · CBI press releases · ED · ACB · The Hindu · NDTV · Business Standard · The Wire
🐙 Crony Watch — Government Contracts
🏭 The Adani Case, Favourable Treatment & Contract Surge Since 2014
⚠ What is and isn’t measured

There is no public dataset for “Adani’s share of total government contracts,” so this page does not claim one. What is documented, and what this tracker relies on, is the specific, sourced record: which assets Adani won, when, under what rules, and how its sector share moved. Any percentage of the overall contract pool below is an explicitly-labelled estimate (±8 pts); everything tagged Verified traces to a named source.

0 → 8
Airports operated (2014 → now)
✔ VERIFIABLE
0 → ~25%
Share of India’s air passengers
✔ VERIFIABLE
6 / 6
Privatised airports won in 2019
✔ VERIFIABLE
~5 to 8%
Est. share of central infra/defence pool
◆ ESTIMATE
In 2014 Adani operated zero airports and was a ports-focused group. The 0→~25% passenger figure is a measured sector share (Adani Airports / Reuters), not a share of total government contracts.
📈 The Run Since 2014, By the Numbers
Metric2014Now / PeakSource
Gautam Adani net worth ~$7.1 bn ~$116 bn
(2024; peaked ~$137 bn in Aug 2022)
Forbes; Bloomberg Billionaires Index
World wealth ranking outside top 100 3rd richest globally
(Aug 2022, 1st Asian ever in top 3)
Bloomberg (Aug 2022)
Group market cap a fraction of today’s
(Ports already largest private operator)
~₹19.2 lakh cr
(peak, Jan 2023, 10 listed firms)
Business Standard; Statista (₹1.31 tn FY20 → ₹15.58 tn FY22)
Listed group companies ~4 ~10 to 11
(Ent, Ports, Power, Green, Energy Solns, Total Gas, Wilmar, Ambuja, ACC, NDTV…)
Exchange filings; Trade Brains
Major sectors ~4 to 5
(ports, power, coal/mining, gas, edible oil)
~13
(+ airports, cement, media, data centres, defence, copper, roads/rail, green energy)
Business Standard (Nov 2024)
Important: wealth and market-cap growth track stock prices and an aggressive expansion strategy, they are not, by themselves, proof of government favouritism. The 2023 Hindenburg crash (group m-cap fell from ~₹19.2 lakh cr to ~₹15 lakh cr in days) shows how market-driven these numbers are. The contract-specific evidence below is the relevant part for an accountability tracker.
🧩 From Ports-and-Coal to Almost Everything, The Diversification Spree
YearSector enteredHowStatus
Pre-2014Ports, power, coal/mining, gas, edible oilCore base, Adani Ports already India’s largest private port operator by 2013 to 14.Verified
2019AirportsWon all 6 privatised AAI airports; later Mumbai (2021) & Navi Mumbai (2025).Verified
2020 to 21Green energy at scale, copper, roads/metro/railAdani Green expansion; Kutch Copper refinery (Mundra); transport EPC incubation.Verified
2022CementAcquired Holcim’s Ambuja Cements + ACC for ~$10.5 bn, group’s biggest deal; instantly India’s 2nd-largest cement maker.Verified
2022MediaQuintillion Business Media, then a controlling stake in NDTV (open offer ~₹6 bn); IANS in 2023.Verified
2022 to 235G / data centres, defence & aerospace5G spectrum entry; AdaniConneX data centres; defence/aerospace incubation under AEL.Verified
2023More cementAmbuja buys Sanghi Cement (~₹6,000 cr), post-Hindenburg acquisition.Verified
OngoingInternational portsHaifa (Israel, ~70%), Colombo (Sri Lanka) terminal, expansion beyond India.Verified
The debate in one line: critics argue this near-vertical, debt-funded expansion across regulated, government-gatekept sectors (airports, ports, transmission, defence) reflects preferential treatment; the group’s defenders argue it simply had the scale, capital and execution capacity that few rivals could match after the mid-tier infra players collapsed. Both readings fit the same verified facts, which is why the tracker presents the record, not a verdict.
📉 The Surge, A Verifiable Timeline
WhenMilestoneStatus
2014Operates 0 airports. Already India’s largest private port operator (Mundra, the largest private commercial port since 2013).Verified
Feb 2019Wins all six privatised AAI airports, Ahmedabad, Lucknow, Jaipur, Mangaluru, Guwahati, Thiruvananthapuram, on 50-year leases, despite no prior airport experience.Verified
2020Union Cabinet clears the leases; concession agreements signed with AAI.Verified
2021Acquires Mumbai airport (MIAL) from GVK (transaction reported ~₹15,000 cr), becomes India’s largest private airport operator.Verified
FY24Airport-segment revenue ~₹8,062 cr, up ~35% year-on-year (company disclosure).Verified
Dec 2025Navi Mumbai International Airport opens (74% Adani stake; phase-1 cost ~₹19,650 cr).Verified
Now8 airports; ~25% of India’s air passengers, ~33% of air cargo. Bidding for 11+ more in the next privatisation round (~$11 bn expansion).Verified
⚖ The Favourable-Treatment Case, What the Record Shows
  1. Experience requirement waived. A bidder’s prior track record is normally evaluated before a PPP award. For these airports the prior-experience clause was dropped, the appraisal committee ruled it could be “neither a prerequisite for bidding, nor a post-bid requirement.” (The Indian Express; AdaniWatch)
  2. Two government bodies objected and were overruled. The Dept of Economic Affairs urged a cap of 2 airports per bidder given the financial risk; NITI Aayog warned an inexperienced bidder could jeopardise service quality. Both were overruled, and Adani won all six. (Indian Express, documents accessed Jan 2021)
  3. Processed at “breakneck speed.” Reporting and AAI employee-union litigation flagged the unusually fast bidding and a missing Request-for-Qualification stage. (NewsClick; AdaniWatch)
  4. The cap appeared, only afterwards. Once Adani had swept all six, the finance ministry and cabinet secretariat began pressing for a 2-airport-per-bidder cap on future rounds, an implicit acknowledgement of how unusual the clean sweep was. (Business Standard, Feb 2020)
For balance, the other side. The government and Adani maintain the airports were awarded through transparent competitive bidding, with Adani the highest bidder on revenue-per-passenger, and argue that requiring prior airport experience would needlessly shrink the bidder pool. SEBI dismissed the Hindenburg stock-manipulation allegations (Sept 2025); in 2026 the US SEC settled without any admission of guilt and the DOJ moved to drop its criminal charges. Adani denies all wrongdoing. A fair reading: the favourable-treatment pattern is documented; proof of illegality is not.
✔ Source Ledger
FactDetailSourceStatus
Airports 2014 → now0 → 8 airports; ~25% of passengers, ~33% of cargo; largest operator.Adani Airports; Deccan Herald (Dec 2025); ReutersVerified
Rules waivedDEA 2-airport cap + NITI Aayog objection overruled; prior-experience clause dropped.The Indian Express; Business Standard; ScrollVerified
Mumbai & Navi MumbaiMIAL acquired from GVK (2021, ~₹15,000 cr reported); Navi Mumbai opens Dec 2025 (~₹19,650 cr phase 1).Business Standard; Deccan HeraldVerified
US legal caseNov 2024 DOJ/SEC indictment (~$265M alleged bribery, solar; denied). SEBI dismissed Hindenburg (Sep 2025). 2026: SEC settled (~$18M, no admission), DOJ dropped charges, Treasury settled (~$275M, Iran sanctions).DOJ/SEC filings; CNBC; Al JazeeraBoth sides
“CAG bid-rigging” flag (Megha)Removed, unsubstantiated; CAG/JJM findings name other contractors, not Megha.CAG Karnataka JJM; ED Rajasthan FIRCorrected
Top-5 share of infra pool~18% (2014) → ~32% (now), midpoint. Estimate only, ±8 pts, no public dataset exists.Author estimate; LSE/Jindal study (context)Estimate
📡 Live Contract & Tender News
Fetching latest contract news...
🎁 State Freebie & Welfare Tracker · All 29 States · Budget 2025 to 26
What this tracks: Welfare schemes and freebies as % of total state budget, cost, beneficiaries, fiscal impact and trend across governments. Sources: CAG, Finance Commission, state budget documents, RBI State Finances report.
₹4.2L Cr
Combined Annual Freebie Spend
1.9%
% of GDP (2025 to 26)
7
States RBI Flagged Unsustainable
SC PIL
Ashwini Upadhyay vs UoI, Pending
State CM / Party Key Schemes Annual Cost State Budget % Budget Fiscal Impact Status
Karnataka D.K. Shivakumar
Congress · since 3 Jun 2026
Siddaramaiah stepped down May 2026
Gruha Jyoti 200 units free · Gruha Lakshmi ₹2000/woman/month · Anna Bhagya 10kg rice · Shakti free bus · Yuva Nidhi ₹3000 unemployed ₹52,000 Cr ₹2,36,000 Cr 22% ₹63K Cr deficit · CAG flagged · FRBM breach CAG Alert
Maharashtra Devendra Fadnavis
BJP-Mahayuti
Ladki Bahin ₹1500/month · Namo Shetkari farm relief · Crop loan waiver ₹1L · Free pilgrimage seniors ₹46,000 Cr ₹2,40,000 Cr 19% Debt ₹7.8L Cr · Credit rating watch · Pre-election surge Active
Tamil Nadu C. Joseph Vijay
TVK · since 10 May 2026
DMK lost 2026 election; schemes below are DMK-era
Kalaignar Magalir Urimai ₹1000/month · Free electricity 100 units · Free bus women · Breakfast Scheme schools · Ungal Thoguthiyil CM ₹32,000 Cr ₹1,88,000 Cr 17% FRBM breach · Debt ₹7.1L Cr · 3.2% GSDP deficit FRBM Breach
Andhra Pradesh N. Chandrababu Naidu
TDP-BJP
Super Six: Free LPG cylinder · Free bus women · Deepam ₹1500/month · Annadata Sukhibhava farmers · Anna Canteen meals ₹24,000 Cr ₹1,72,000 Cr 14% Partial rollback post-audit · Naidu reversing YSRCP excess Under Review
Telangana Revanth Reddy
Congress
Rythu Bharosa ₹12K/farmer · Free agriculture power · Mahalakshmi free bus women · Indiramma housing · Fee reimbursement ₹19,800 Cr ₹1,32,000 Cr 15% Revenue deficit ₹12K Cr · Promises exceed revenue Active
Punjab Bhagwant Mann
AAP
Free electricity 300 units/month · ₹1000/month women · Aam Aadmi Clinics free medicines · Free school uniforms · Free bus women ₹18,500 Cr ₹77,000 Cr 24% Debt ₹3.27L Cr (47% GSDP) · Highest debt ratio in India RBI Flagged
Rajasthan Bhajan Lal Sharma
BJP
Free electricity 100 units · Mukhyamantri Ayushman Arogya insurance · Palanhar yojana · Indira Gandhi Smartphone (Congress era retained) ₹16,000 Cr ₹1,23,000 Cr 13% Debt ₹5.6L Cr · RBI OD 42 days FY25 Active
Madhya Pradesh Mohan Yadav
BJP
Ladli Behna ₹1500/month · Free rice PDS 35kg · PM Awas rural housing supplement · Mukhyamantri Teerth Darshan pilgrimage ₹14,500 Cr ₹1,32,000 Cr 11% Manageable, central transfers offset Active
Uttar Pradesh Yogi Adityanath
BJP
Free ration 5kg (80Cr nationally) · Mukhyamantri Kanya Sumangala · Free electricity BPL 100 units · Kisan Karj Mafi partial ₹12,000 Cr ₹2,40,000 Cr 5% Largest state budget, low % despite high absolute Active
Delhi Rekha Gupta
BJP
200 units free electricity · Free water 20KL/month · Free DTC bus women · Mohalla Clinics · Free medicines (AAP schemes retained) ₹11,200 Cr ₹80,000 Cr 14% Surplus state · High tax base · Manageable Active
Jharkhand Hemant Soren
JMM
Maiya Samman ₹2500/month women · Free rice 5kg · Abua Awas housing · Free electricity 100 units BPL ₹9,600 Cr ₹60,000 Cr 16% CAG: implementation gaps · Ghost beneficiaries found CAG Flagged
West Bengal Suvendu Adhikari
BJP · since 9 May 2026
TMC lost 2026 election; schemes below are TMC-era
Lakshmir Bhandar ₹1000/month · Kanyashree · Rupashree marriage grant ₹25K · Free ration · Swasthya Sathi health insurance ₹9,200 Cr ₹77,000 Cr 12% Debt ₹6.3L Cr · RBI flagged · Salary delays RBI Flagged
Bihar Samrat Choudhary
BJP-JDU NDA · since 15 Apr 2026
Nitish Kumar moved to Rajya Sabha
Mukhyamantri Kanya Utthan ₹50K girls · Free cycles girls · Har Ghar Bijli 50 units BPL · Jeevika SHG support ₹8,800 Cr ₹88,000 Cr 10% Special category state · Central grants support Active
Odisha Mohan Majhi
BJP
Subhadra Yojana ₹10K/year women · KALIA farmer ₹10K/year · Free ration · Mission Shakti SHG support ₹7,400 Cr ₹67,000 Cr 11% Mineral revenues offset · Manageable position Active
Gujarat Bhupendra Patel
BJP
Free electricity farmers · Mukhyamantri Mahila Utkarsh ₹1L SHG loans · Free LPG BPL · Kisan Suryoday solar power ₹6,800 Cr ₹97,000 Cr 7% Industrial revenue base · Low % · Fiscally stable Active
Chhattisgarh Vishnu Deo Sai
BJP
Mahtari Vandan ₹1000/month women · Free rice 35kg · PM Awas Plus supplement · Free electricity 100 units ₹5,600 Cr ₹51,000 Cr 11% Coal royalties offset freebie cost · Moderate position Active
Kerala V.D. Satheesan
Congress-UDF · since 18 May 2026
LDF lost 2026 election; schemes below are LDF-era
Free ration PDS · Aashraya housing · Fee waiver professional colleges · Free medicines public hospitals · Karunya health ₹5,200 Cr ₹47,000 Cr 11% Debt ₹3.8L Cr · 38% GSDP · CAG revenue warning CAG Alert
Haryana Nayab Singh Saini
BJP
Lado Protsahan ₹2.1L girls at birth · Free bus travel women · Mukhyamantri Parivar Samridhi ₹6K/year · PM Kisan top-up ₹4,900 Cr ₹49,000 Cr 10% Industrial base manageable · Pre-election boost 2024 Active
Assam Himanta Biswa Sarma
BJP
Orunodoi ₹1250/month women · Free rice 5kg · Mukhyamantri Mahila Udyamita · Arunodoi 2.0 expansion ₹4,200 Cr ₹32,000 Cr 13% NE special grants offset · Manageable Active
Himachal Pradesh Sukhwinder Singh Sukhu
Congress
Indira Gandhi Pyari Behna ₹1500/month · Free electricity 125 units · Free bus women · OPS pension restored ₹3,600 Cr ₹20,000 Cr 18% Debt crisis · Salary delays reported · CAG critical alert CAG Alert
Uttarakhand Pushkar Singh Dhami
BJP
Mukhyamantri Mahila Sashaktikaran · Free electricity 100 units BPL · Mukhyamantri Swarojgar loans · Free ration ₹3,100 Cr ₹31,000 Cr 10% Tourism revenues help · Moderate position Active
Goa Pramod Sawant
BJP
Ladli Laxmi · Griha Aadhar ₹3600/month women · Free electricity 100 units BPL · Dayanand Social Security pension ₹2,800 Cr ₹31,000 Cr 9% Tourism + mining revenue · Manageable Active
Manipur Y. Khemchand Singh
BJP · since 4 Feb 2026
After a year of President's Rule
Free ration · CM-DATTS health scheme · Free textbooks · MGNREGS enhanced wages · Conflict relief packages ₹2,400 Cr ₹20,000 Cr 12% Conflict-affected · Heavy central aid dependency Active
Tripura Manik Saha
BJP
Mukhyamantri Matri Pushti Upahaar · Free electricity 75 units BPL · Banglar Bari housing · Free ration BPL ₹1,900 Cr ₹17,000 Cr 11% NE special grants · Manageable Active
Meghalaya Conrad Sangma
NPP
CM Socio Economic Scheme · Free electricity BPL · Megha Health Insurance · Free textbooks students ₹1,700 Cr ₹17,000 Cr 10% NE grants manageable · Small state Active
Nagaland Neiphiu Rio
NDPP-BJP
Free ration BPL · CM Health Insurance · Startup Mission grants · Free textbooks · Skill development stipends ₹1,500 Cr ₹15,000 Cr 10% NE special category · Stable Active
Arunachal Pradesh Pema Khandu
BJP
CM Krishi Sa Yog farmers · Free electricity BPL · CM Arogya Arunachal health scheme · Free textbooks ₹1,200 Cr ₹13,000 Cr 9% Hydro revenues stable · Low burden Active
Mizoram Lalduhoma
ZPM
Free ration · SEDP social welfare grants · CM Development Project · Free medicines PHC ₹900 Cr ₹10,000 Cr 9% Small state · NE grants · Manageable Active
Sikkim Prem Singh Tamang
SKM
Social Security pension · Old Age Pension ₹3K/month · Free electricity 200 units · Free healthcare state hospitals ₹800 Cr ₹10,000 Cr 8% Hydro revenues · Most comfortable NE state Active
🏛 Party-wise Average Freebie % of State Budget
Party / AllianceStates GovernedAvg % of BudgetAvg Absolute CostTrend Since Coming to PowerNotable
AAPPunjab19%₹14,850 Cr avg↑ Highest increase on entryFree electricity model copied by all parties
CongressKarnataka, Telangana, HP, Himachal17%₹21,400 Cr avg↑ Sharp jump on election winGuarantee model, 5 promises pre-election
BJPMP, Raj, UP, Guj, Har, CG, Odi, Delhi, etc.11-14%₹8,600 Cr avg↑ Moderate increase, matching rivalsLadli Behna / Ladki Bahin pattern; in Delhi, largely retained AAP's existing subsidies after Feb 2025
Regional (DMK, TMC, JMM, etc.)TN, WB, Jharkhand, Sikkim, etc.13%₹9,200 Cr avg↑ Steady rise each termState-specific identity-based freebies
Correction: AAP lost power in Delhi in the February 2025 Assembly election; BJP's Rekha Gupta became Chief Minister, ending 27 years without a BJP government there. AAP now governs Punjab only. The figures above predate that change and have not yet been recomputed on a Punjab-only basis, so treat the 19%/₹14,850 Cr AAP row as provisional until we can re-source it; Delhi's own current numbers (BJP, 14% of budget) are in the state-by-state tracker above.
Key finding: Even accounting for Delhi's change of government, high-welfare-spend states cluster around a similar range regardless of party, Congress-run states currently show the highest average (17%), with BJP and regional-party states somewhat lower. Karnataka under Congress jumped from 8% to 22% of budget, the highest in India. Punjab under AAP carries the most dangerous debt trajectory at 47% of GSDP. The 16th Finance Commission is reviewing whether freebie spending should count against FRBM limits.
📡 Live State Budget & Welfare News
Fetching latest welfare scheme news...
⚖ JUDGES ACCOUNTABILITY · CORRUPTION CHARGES · ELEVATION BLOCKED · REWARDED
Judges facing CBI / SC in-house inquiry for corruption or misconduct. Separate from the General Tracker (politicians). Sources: CBI · SC in-house inquiry records · Bar Council · Bar & Bench · LiveLaw · RTI.
Judge Court / Position Charge / Allegation Agency Status
Justice Yashwant Varma
⚖ JUDGE
Fmr Judge, Allahabad HC
(Fmr Delhi HC judge)
Unaccounted cash (alleged ₹15 Cr+) discovered at official bungalow during fire, Mar 2025. SC in-house inquiry committee, set up by then-CJI Sanjiv Khanna, found him guilty and recommended removal. 146+ MPs moved a Lok Sabha impeachment motion in Jul 2025. He resigned on 9 April 2026, before the statutory committee finished its hearings, avoiding a Parliament vote. Lawyers say resignation ends his judicial immunity, opening the door to prosecution. Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla decided in July 2026 to table the committee's report regardless, an unprecedented test of whether resignation can extinguish a pending impeachment probe. SC In-House Cmte Resigned · Report Tabled
Justice (Retd.) Nirmal Yadav
⚖ JUDGE
Fmr Judge, Punjab & Haryana HC Cash-at-doorstep bribery 2008, ₹15 lakh intended for another judge delivered to her residence instead. CBI chargesheet filed. Trial dragging 15+ years with repeated adjournments. No conviction yet. CBI Trial Ongoing · 15+ Yrs
Justice (Retd.) I.M. Quddusi
⚖ JUDGE
Fmr Judge, Orissa HC Arrested by CBI in 2017 for allegedly conspiring to influence SC bench in a medical college seat-allotment case in exchange for money. Audio recordings produced as evidence. Trial ongoing. CBI Trial Ongoing
Sources: SC in-house inquiry records · CBI · Bar Council of India · Bar & Bench · LiveLaw · RTI disclosures
Pattern: Judges who ruled against the ruling party faced systematic career penalties, transfers, blocked elevations, reduced seniority, with no statutory protection or independent review mechanism. India has no legal safeguard against executive retaliation on judicial careers.
Judge Verdict That Triggered Retaliation What Happened to Elevation Outcome
Justice Akil Kureshi
Gujarat / Bombay / Tripura / Rajasthan HC
2010: Remanded Amit Shah to 2-day CBI custody in Sohrabuddin Sheikh fake encounter case.
2012: Upheld Governor's appointment of Justice R.A. Mehta as Lokayukta, setback for Modi govt.
Became India's 2nd-most-senior HC judge nationally.
2018: Transferred to Bombay HC (lower seniority) as he was about to become Gujarat HC Acting CJ, bypassed by junior judge.
May 2019: Collegium recommended him as MP HC CJ. Centre sat on file for months; sent "material" twice rejecting his name. Collegium downgraded recommendation to smaller Tripura HC.
2021: Not elevated to SC despite being most senior HC CJ. Two vacancies filled by junior judges. Gujarat HC Advocates Association filed SC petition, Fali Nariman and Dushyant Dave appeared for him.
Retired Mar 2022, Never Elevated to SC
Justice K.M. Joseph
Uttarakhand HC Chief Justice
Apr 2016: Struck down President's Rule imposed by Modi government in Congress-ruled Uttarakhand, restored CM Harish Rawat's government. Widely seen as landmark check on executive overreach. Jan 2018: SC Collegium unanimously recommended his SC elevation.
Apr 2018: Centre rejected, cited seniority, "over-representation" of Kerala judges.
Justice Chelameswar dissented sharply in Collegium records. Congress called it "revenge politics."
Aug 2018: Centre finally cleared, but at lower seniority than two simultaneously elevated judges, depressing his future CJI prospects.
Eventually Elevated, 7-month delay, seniority lowered
Justice Jayant Patel
Gujarat HC / Karnataka HC
2010 to 11: Supervised SIT probe into Sohrabuddin Sheikh encounter case implicating BJP leaders. CBI chargesheet naming IB and Gujarat police officials filed during his oversight. Transferred from Gujarat HC (as he was next for Acting CJ) to Allahabad HC in 2016 at reduced seniority, then again to Karnataka HC. Collegium bypassed him for CJ appointments despite seniority. Resigned Sep 2017 in protest, Never Elevated
Adv. Gopal Subramanium
SC Judge Designate (2014)
Served as amicus curiae (court-appointed counsel) in cases against Amit Shah in Sohrabuddin encounter case before his SC elevation was recommended by Collegium, Jun 2014. Collegium recommended SC elevation with three others. Centre cleared all three but selectively returned only Subramanium's file within days of Modi taking office. No formal reason given. Subramanium withdrew citing "malicious and disparaging material" sent to CJI by government. Withdrew consent, Selectively blocked Jun 2014
Sources: SC Collegium resolutions (public) · LiveLaw · Bar & Bench · SC Observer · Lawfare Media · RTI disclosures · Justice Gogoi autobiography
RAT = Retirement After Tenure. Post-retirement govt appointments given to judges. India has no mandatory cooling-off period for judges before accepting govt roles. Critics argue this creates a structural incentive for judicial deference during tenure. The pattern: key pro-govt verdict → rapid appointment within months of retirement.
Judge Key Verdict Benefiting Ruling Party Post-Retirement RAT Role Gap Flag
Justice Ranjan Gogoi
Retd. CJI (Nov 2019)
Ayodhya verdict (Ram Mandir, unanimous, Nov 2019) · Rafale case dismissed · Assam NRC supervised · Own sexual harassment case handled by bench he nominated Rajya Sabha MP, Nominated
Nominated by President (Modi govt's advice)
4 months RAT · RS Nomination
Justice Arun Mishra
Retd. SC Judge (Sep 2020)
Called PM Modi "versatile genius" in open court (2020), condemned as unprecedented judicial sycophancy · Upheld electoral bonds scheme · Multiple land acquisition rulings in govt favour NHRC Chairperson
National Human Rights Commission
1 month RAT · NHRC Chair
Justice A.K. Sikri
Retd. SC Judge (Mar 2019)
Casting vote to remove CBI Director Alok Verma, 2-2 split, his vote was decisive. Verma had been reinstated by SC days earlier; removal benefited the government directly. Commonwealth Secretariat Arbitral Tribunal, London 2 months RAT · International Post
Justice P.C. Ghose
Retd. SC Judge (May 2019)
Part of Rafale bench that dismissed probe petition, ₹59,000 Cr deal cleared from judicial scrutiny · Part of electoral bonds bench that upheld scheme (later struck down 2024) First Lokpal of India
India's top anti-corruption ombudsman
1 month RAT · Lokpal Chief
Pattern note: The above cases do not individually prove judicial bias. What they document is a structural incentive problem: judges face zero institutional cost for rulings that benefit the ruling party, while those who rule against it face documented career consequences. India has no cooling-off period, no independent audit of RAT roles, and no disclosure requirement for judges' communications with the executive. Sources: SC Collegium resolutions · RTI · Bar & Bench · LiveLaw · SC Observer.
🏛 Bench Watch · Supreme Court Judges · Verdicts & Elevation Patterns
What this tracks: Sitting and recently elevated SC/HC judges, notable verdicts before elevation, post-retirement appointments (RAT) given by the executive, and patterns of judicial deference to the incumbent government. Sources: Supreme Court records, Bar & Bench, LiveLaw, Livelaw, RTI disclosures.
Judge Current Position Notable Verdicts Post-Retirement Role Flag
Justice Arun Mishra
Retd. SC Judge
Chairperson
National Human Rights Commission
Called PM Modi "versatile genius" in open court (2020) · Upheld electoral bonds scheme · Ruled in favour of govt in land acquisition cases NHRC Chair
Appointed by Modi Govt 2021 · 3-yr term
RAT Appointment
Justice Ranjan Gogoi
Retd. CJI
Rajya Sabha MP
Nominated
Ayodhya verdict (Ram Mandir, unanimous, Nov 2019) · Rafale case dismissed · Assam NRC supervised · Own sexual harassment case handled by bench he nominated RS MP, Nominated
Nominated by President (Modi Govt) Mar 2020 · 4 months after retirement
RAT, RS Nomination
Justice S.A. Bobde
Retd. CJI
No formal appointment
Declined publicly
Stayed farm laws protests petitions · Stayed CAA petitions · Formed committees instead of ruling on electoral bonds · Did not list Pegasus case urgently No RAT appointment
Declined post-retirement roles, publicly noted
No RAT
Justice N.V. Ramana
Retd. CJI
No formal appointment
Private practice
Struck down sedition law enforcement (2022) · Criticised govt on judicial vacancies · Pegasus case, appointed technical committee · Cleared Lakhimpur Kheri case monitoring No RAT appointment
Considered relatively independent
Independent
Justice U.U. Lalit
Retd. CJI
No formal appointment Electoral bonds, referred to Constitution Bench · Shorter tenure as CJI (74 days) · Demonetisation judgment (upheld 4-1) · Struck down some sedition applications No RAT appointment No RAT
Justice D.Y. Chandrachud
Retd. CJI
No formal appointment yet
Retired Nov 2024
Electoral bonds, struck down (landmark) · Demonetisation, upheld 4-1 · Ayodhya, part of bench · Section 377, decriminalised · Article 370, upheld abrogation · Met PM Modi privately (flagged by Bar) Watch, retired Nov 2024
No RAT appointment publicly reported as of Sept 2026
Watch
Justice Sanjiv Khanna
Retd. CJI (51st)
Was Chief Justice of India
Nov 2024 to May 2025
Electoral bonds, part of Constitution Bench (struck down) · VVPAT case, dismissed full verification demand · Article 370, upheld abrogation · Delhi CM arrest, granted bail to Kejriwal · As CJI, recommended Justice Varma's removal after the in-house cash-scandal inquiry Retired May 2025
No RAT appointment publicly reported as of Sept 2026
Watch
Justice B.R. Gavai
Retd. CJI (52nd)
Was Chief Justice of India
May 2025 to Nov 2025, 6 months
First CJI from a Scheduled Caste background in this century; second Dalit CJI after K.G. Balakrishnan Retired Nov 2025
No RAT appointment publicly reported as of Sept 2026
Watch
Justice Surya Kant
Current CJI (53rd)
Chief Justice of India
Since 24 Nov 2025
Sworn in as India's 53rd CJI; tenure runs to 9 Feb 2027 (~15 months) Serving CJI
Retires Feb 2027
Serving
Justice Yashwant Varma
Fmr Judge, Allahabad HC
Resigned
Was transferred from Delhi HC
Unaccounted cash found at official residence during fire, 14 Mar 2025 · SC in-house inquiry (under then-CJI Khanna) found him guilty, recommended removal · 146+ MPs moved a Lok Sabha impeachment motion, Jul 2025 · Resigned 9 Apr 2026, before the statutory inquiry committee concluded, avoiding a Parliament vote · Lawyers say resignation ends his judicial immunity, opening the door to prosecution · Lok Sabha Speaker decided in Jul 2026 to table the committee's report anyway, an unprecedented move testing whether resignation can extinguish a pending impeachment probe Resigned Apr 2026
Report tabled regardless, Jul 2026
Resigned · Report Tabled
🔄 RAT Tracker · Retirement After Tenure Appointments Since 2014
RAT (Retirement After Tenure), Post-retirement government appointments given to judges. Critics argue this creates incentive for judicial deference during tenure. India has no mandatory cooling-off period for judges unlike many democracies.
JudgeRetired AsRAT RoleGapKey Context
Justice Ranjan GogoiCJI (Nov 2019)Rajya Sabha MP, Nominated4 monthsAyodhya Ram Mandir · Rafale dismissed · NRC
Justice Arun MishraSC Judge (Sep 2020)NHRC Chairperson1 monthCalled Modi "versatile genius" · Electoral bonds upheld
Justice A.K. SikriSC Judge (Mar 2019)Commonwealth Secretariat Arbitral Tribunal (London)2 monthsAlok Verma CBI Director case, voted to remove
Justice P.C. GhoseSC Judge (May 2019)First Lokpal of India1 monthRafale bench · Electoral bonds bench
Justice S.J. MukhopadhayaSC Judge (2014)NCLAT Chairperson6 monthsEarly Modi era appointments
Justice R.C. LahotiCJI (2005)Various arbitration panels2 yearsUPA era, pattern predates Modi
📺 Media Watch · Ownership · Govt Ad Spend · ED/CBI Cases
What this tracks: Who owns India's top news outlets, government advertising (DAVP) flowing to each, and ED/CBI cases filed against media owners. Data note: Per-channel FY25 DAVP breakdowns are not published by the government. Figures below show what RTI and parliamentary sources have actually confirmed, mostly from FY2017 to 22. Sources: MIB parliamentary replies, Newslaundry RTI data, ED press releases, company filings.
⚠ Why per-channel FY25 crore figures are not shown: The total DAVP + CBC TV/audio-visual spend in FY 2024 to 25 was ₹406 crore across all channels combined (Rajya Sabha Q.894, Dec 2025). Per-channel breakdowns for FY25 have not been officially released. Figures like "₹820 Cr to Network18" that circulate online are not sourced to any government document and are mathematically impossible given the total budget.
Media House Owner Key Channels Verified Govt Ad Revenue
(RTI / Parliamentary data)
ED / CBI Cases Stance
Network18 / TV18 Reliance (Mukesh Ambani)
Acquired 2022
CNN-News18 · CNBC-TV18 · News18 India · 20+ regional channels · Firstpost ₹9 Cr
Central DAVP, FY2020 to 22
Source: Newslaundry RTI 2022
No active cases · Reliance acquired post-2022 Pro-Govt
Zee Media Subhash Chandra / Essel Group Zee News · Wion · Zee Business · 15+ channels ₹7.8 Cr
Central DAVP, FY2020 to 22
Source: Newslaundry RTI 2022
ED: ₹2,000 Cr FEMA case Subhash Chandra · Charges later dropped · Debt restructured with govt bank support Pro-Govt
India TV Rajat Sharma
BJP-linked journalist
India TV Hindi · India TV English ₹7.06 Cr
Central DAVP, FY2019 RTI
Source: Newslaundry RTI 2022
No cases · Rajat Sharma personal friend of PM Modi Pro-Govt
Aaj Tak / India Today Aroon Purie / Living Media Aaj Tak · India Today TV · Headlines Today · Lallantop ₹3.7 Cr
Central DAVP, FY2017 to 18
Source: MIB Rajya Sabha reply (Newslaundry 2021)
No active cases · Occasional critical coverage Mixed / Centrist
NDTV Adani Group
Acquired Nov 2022
NDTV 24x7 · NDTV India · NDTV Profit ₹1.55 lakh
NDTV India (Hindi) FY2017 to 18
Near-zero across years pre-acquisition
Source: MIB RTI / parliamentary data (Newslaundry 2021)
ED: FEMA case founders Prannoy/Radhika Roy · Cases active during hostile takeover bid · Founders left post-acquisition Takeover via ED pressure, alleged
Republic TV Arnab Goswami
ARG Outlier Media
Republic TV · Republic Bharat · Republic World Not listed / ₹0
Missing from DAVP reports, govt data inconsistency flagged
Source: Newslaundry RTI 2021 & 2022
Mumbai Police: abetment to suicide FIR 2020 · WhatsApp leaks showed coordination with BJP · TRP manipulation case CBI Pro-Govt · TRP Case
The Wire Foundation for Independent Journalism The Wire (English/Hindi) · Science The Wire ₹0
All years, never received DAVP
Source: MIB data; Wire's own verified disclosures
Multiple defamation cases filed by BJP leaders · IT notices · Founders homes raided · Meta fact-check partnership pressured Critical · Targeted
NewsClick Prabir Purkayastha NewsClick (Digital) ₹0
All years, no DAVP
Source: MIB data / NewsClick
UAPA case Oct 2023 · Founder arrested · 100+ journalists raided · Supreme Court granted bail after 6 months Critical · UAPA Arrest
The Hindu Kasturi & Sons / N. Ram The Hindu · BusinessLine · Sportstar Some print DAVP
Exact FY25 figures not disaggregated in public data; receives standard print allocation. IT notices issued for Rafale source.
No active cases · Broke Rafale documents story · IT notices for source Independent / Critical
What the verified data shows: Network18 got ~₹9 Cr and Zee ~₹7.8 Cr in central DAVP TV ads in FY2020 to 22 (Newslaundry RTI). NDTV Hindi received just ₹1.55 lakh in FY2017 to 18. The Wire and NewsClick received ₹0 across all years. Total DAVP TV/AV spend in FY25 was ₹406 Cr across all channels (Rajya Sabha Q.894, Dec 2025), no per-channel FY25 breakdown has been published. NDTV founders faced active ED/FEMA cases during Adani's hostile takeover bid, cases were dropped after Adani gained control. India ranked 159th / 180 on RSF Press Freedom Index 2024 (improved to 157th in 2026), down from 140th in 2014.
📢 "Fair & Balanced", How Your Tax Money Buys the News You Watch
The 4th Pillar Is Quietly Being Renovated, With Public Funds

Democracy's press freedom rests on one axiom: the government and the press are adversaries by design. India's Constitution guarantees freedom of speech; the Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed a free press as fundamental to democracy. Yet since 2014, the Modi government has spent over ₹2,447 crore in public money on "advertising" to private news channels across FY2020 to 25 alone (Rajya Sabha Q, Dec 2025), money that does not buy government airtime so much as it buys editorial goodwill. The pattern, verified from Parliamentary data and RTI responses, is unmistakable: channels that run sympathetic coverage receive crores in DAVP ad money; channels that ask inconvenient questions receive close to zero, or receive an ED raid instead. India's press freedom rank has fallen from 140th to 159th out of 180 countries (RSF 2024; improved slightly to 157th in RSF 2026) under this system. Below is the data that the news channels themselves will never show you.

₹2,447 Cr
Total Govt ad spend (all media) FY2020 to 21 to FY2024 to 25 · Source: MIB Rajya Sabha reply, MP Shafi Parambil question, Dec 2025
₹406 Cr
Total AV (TV/Radio) ad spend FY 2024 to 25 · Up 39.1% YoY · Source: Rajya Sabha Q.894
157/180
India's RSF Press Freedom rank 2026 · Was 159/180 in 2024, 140/180 in 2014 · Source: RSF 2024 & 2026 indices
₹0
DAVP spend on The Wire, NewsClick, Scroll, critical outlets combined · "Coincidence"
📊 Year-Wise Government Ad Spend, The Firehose & The Famine
Financial Year Total Spend (₹ Cr) Electronic / TV Print Political Context
2018 to 19 ₹1,179 Cr ₹514 Cr ₹430 Cr Pre-election year, highest spend on record
2019 to 20 ₹708 Cr ₹317 Cr ₹295 Cr Election year 2019, then post-election pullback
2020 to 21 ₹409 Cr ₹168 Cr ₹197 Cr COVID year, but PM CARES gets zero scrutiny
2021 to 22 ₹316 Cr ₹101 Cr ₹179 Cr Post-COVID recovery · Print share overtakes TV briefly
2022 to 23 ₹408 Cr ₹155 Cr ₹220 Cr Pre-election state budgets surge · Network18 acquired by Reliance
2023 to 24 ₹494 Cr ₹292 Cr ₹202 Cr Pre-Lok Sabha election surge · Print up 2× in 2 years
2024 to 25 ₹526 Cr ₹406 Cr ▲39% ₹120 Cr TV/digital surges 39% YoY · AV now 77% of all govt ad spend · I&B Ministry alone: ₹208 Cr (40%)
Sources: Ministry of Information & Broadcasting written reply, Rajya Sabha Q.894 (Dec 2025) · Deccan Herald (Jul 2023) · Storyboard18 (Feb 2026) · Newslaundry RTI data 2020 to 21
📺 Channel-Wise Government Ad Money, Who Gets the Gravy & Who Gets the CBI
Channel / Group Govt Ad Revenue
FY2019 (DAVP RTI)
Govt Ad Revenue
FY2023 (Parl. data)
ED / CBI Status Editorial Posture Verdict
Zee News / Zee Media
Subhash Chandra / Essel Group · 15+ channels
₹10.95 Cr ₹5.33 Cr ED: ₹2,000 Cr FEMA case on Subhash Chandra · Charges later dropped after behaviour change Consistently pro-BJP · Anchor Sudhir Chaudhary (ex-Zee) later hired by Doordarshan for ₹15 to 18 Cr/yr package Funded · Charges Dropped
News18 India / CNN-News18
Reliance (Mukesh Ambani) since 2022 · Network18 Group
₹8.6 Cr Not published
Per-channel FY25 DAVP data not released by govt. Total AV budget: ₹406 Cr all channels (RS Q.894)
No active cases · Reliance is India's largest private company, structural immunity Post-2022 acquisition: critical coverage of Modi government effectively ceased · Anchors who asked hard questions quietly dropped Largest Recipient
Republic TV / Republic Bharat
Arnab Goswami · ARG Outlier Media
₹71.6 L (launched 2019) Not published
Missing from or ₹0 in DAVP data for FY2020 to 22 (Newslaundry RTI)
Mumbai Police: abetment to suicide 2020 · WhatsApp leaks showed coordination with BJP leaders · TRP manipulation CBI case Prime-time shouting at opposition · Anchor's WhatsApp chats with BARC CEO (alleged TRP rigging) leaked; no conviction Funded · Case Stalled
India TV
Rajat Sharma, BJP-linked; personal friend of PM Modi
₹7.06 Cr Not published
Per-channel FY25 breakdown not released
No cases · Personal access to PM Modi for "Aap Ki Adalat" format Rajat Sharma was BJP youth wing member before journalism career · Granted exclusive PM interview access during every election cycle Funded · Clean Slate
Aaj Tak / India Today TV
Aroon Purie / Living Media Group
₹3.7 Cr Not published
Per-channel FY25 breakdown not released
No cases · TV Today Group · Occasional critical coverage preserved Maintains some editorial independence · Breaks occasional critical stories but largely avoids sustained anti-govt coverage Funded · Mixed
NDTV (pre-Adani)
Prannoy Roy / Radhika Roy, Acquired by Adani Group Nov 2022
₹1.55 L (Hindi) Not published
Pre-acquisition DAVP near-zero; post-Adani not disaggregated
ED: FEMA cases on founders Prannoy/Radhika Roy · Active during hostile takeover · Cases withdrawn after Adani gained control in Nov 2022 Last major independent TV channel · Critical anchors Ravish Kumar, Nidhi Razdan left post-acquisition · RSF called it "takeover under ED pressure" Raided → Acquired → Tamed
NewsClick
Prabir Purkayastha, digital outlet
₹0 ₹0 UAPA arrest Oct 2023 · 100+ journalists raided simultaneously · SC granted bail after 6 months citing rights violated Critical labour, minority, and anti-BJP coverage · zero DAVP · Received UAPA instead of ads ₹0 + UAPA Arrest
The Wire
Foundation for Independent Journalism
₹0 ₹0 Multiple defamation suits by BJP leaders · IT notices · Founders' homes raided · Meta fact-check partnership pressured and ended Broke multiple accountability stories: Rafale, Electoral Bonds, Pegasus · RSF Journalism prize winner · Never received a rupee of DAVP ₹0 + Raids + Suits
NDTV India (Hindi, pre-takeover)
Last major Hindi channel with independent editorial stance
₹1.55 L (entire year) ₹0 (state govts) Multiple ED/FEMA notices · NDTV India briefly taken off air by I&B Ministry (2017), only instance of a major channel being blacked out by govt order Ravish Kumar's primetime shows reported farmer suicides, unemployment, police brutality · Won Ramon Magsaysay award · Resigned Nov 2022 after Adani takeover Blacked Out → Acquired
🏛 Bonus Round: State Governments Join the Fun
State Ad Spend Period Biggest Beneficiary · Who Got Zero Source
Uttar Pradesh (Yogi Adityanath) ₹160 Cr FY 2020 to 21 (1 yr) Network18 group: ₹28.82 Cr · Zee: ₹23.48 Cr · ABP: ₹18.19 Cr · NDTV channels: ₹0 Newslaundry RTI (Jul 2021)
Delhi (AAP, Arvind Kejriwal) ₹491 Cr 2015 to 2022 (7 yrs) Spent heavily on self-promotion · CAG found ₹97 Cr on "freebies" communication including ads · Pattern same across parties, BJP and AAP alike CAG Report 2023 · RTI
Doordarshan (National Public Broadcaster) ₹15 to 18 Cr/yr 2024 onwards Sudhir Chaudhary (ex-Zee, controversy over fake video 2025) hired for DD News at ₹15 to 18 Cr annual package · Fake video aired May 2025 defending BJP, DD apologised but Chaudhary retained Once in a Blue Moon Academia 2025 · Bar & Bench
🧭 THE PATTERN IN ONE TABLE
Outlet Type DAVP / Govt Ads ED / CBI / UAPA Press Freedom Trajectory
Pro-government / captured media (Network18, Zee, Republic, India TV) ₹1,000 to ₹820 Cr+ Charges dropped / None Rising ratings, rising ad money, rising access to PM
Centrist / mixed (Aaj Tak, The Hindu, ABP) Moderate allocation No active cases Maintained independence but avoids sustained anti-BJP campaigns
Independent / critical (The Wire, NewsClick, NDTV pre-2022) ₹0 UAPA · ED · Raids · Takeover Arrested, silenced, acquired, or defunded
DAVP's own policy (Electronic Media Advertisement Policy) says:
"DAVP does not take into account the political affiliation or editorial policies of radio/TV channels while releasing advertisements."
, Survey of India / MIB Electronic Media Advertisement Policy
The Wire received ₹0. NewsClick received ₹0. NDTV (Hindi) received ₹1.55 lakh in an entire year. Coincidence, presumably.
All sources verified: Parliamentary data (MIB written replies, Rajya Sabha Q.894 Dec 2025) · Newslaundry RTI data (2020 to 2021) · Deccan Herald Parl. response reporting (Jul 2023) · Storyboard18 (Feb 2026) · Exchange4media (Jan 2026) · Scroll.in (Jan 2025) · RSF Press Freedom Index 2014 to 2024 · Once in a Blue Moon Academia (May 2025) on Doordarshan/Sudhir Chaudhary
📡 Live Judiciary & Media News
Fetching latest judiciary and media news...
⛽ Ethanol E20
⛽ E20: The Promise & The Pump
Gadkari's assurances vs the ground reality · and how the countries that got ethanol right did it
2025
E20 nationwide, 5 years early
3 to 12%
Reported real-world mileage drop
30 Cr+
Legacy vehicles built for E5 / E10
0
Pumps offering a lower-ethanol choice

India blended 20% ethanol into petrol five years ahead of schedule, then made it the only fuel at nearly every pump, with no consumer choice, no price cut and no label. Here is what the government promised, what drivers are actually reporting, and how the countries that got ethanol right did it differently.

🗣 Gadkari's Promise vs the Ground Reality

Union Road Transport Minister Nitin Gadkari has been the policy's public face. His assurances are on the left; what official Q&As, automakers, drivers and a Supreme Court petition actually show is on the right.

The promise / claim The ground reality Status
"No evidence of engine damage." Gadkari called damage claims a "false narrative" and "propaganda," saying E20 was cleared after extensive ARAI and automaker testing (Jul 2026). A Supreme Court PIL cites engine corrosion, mounting repair bills and insurance claims being rejected for ethanol-related damage. Automakers concede older rubber gaskets / washers may need replacement after ~20,000 km. Disputed
"Mileage impact is marginal." Initially downplayed; later accepted ethanol's lower calorific value can "slightly" cut mileage, mostly on highways. The Petroleum Ministry's own Q&A admits a 3 to 5% drop; SIAM's controlled tests show 2 to 4% (6% in older models) and concede on-road losses run higher. Outlook reports drivers seeing 5 to 12% in real use. Now admitted
Cuts the ₹22 lakh-crore fuel import bill and channels money to farmers (maize & sugarcane prices up). Import-substitution and farm-income gains are real and cited by independent analysts too, but this is the benefit side of a ledger whose costs were loaded onto drivers without their consent or a discount. Partly true
Rolled out only after due process. "Show me a single car damaged by E20." In June 2026 the government's own Attorney General told the Supreme Court the Centre was "experimenting" with E20, sparking national outrage; the government later said he was misunderstood. Credibility gap
A consumer-friendly transition. Flex-fuel vehicles that run on high ethanol are "coming." E20 became the only fuel at almost all pumps in 2025 with no lower-blend option, no price discount and no ethanol label. India's first flex-fuel cars and two-wheelers only arrive in 2026, after the mandate, not before. Reversed order
Sources: India TV interview (14 Jul 2026) · Outlook India (Jul 2026) · Business Standard (14 Jul 2026) · Al Jazeera (15 Jul 2026) · Deccan Herald (SIAM briefing) · Malay Mail / SIAM (31 Aug 2025) · Tribune India (SC PIL) · Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas Q&A.
For balance, the government's case.
Ministers argue E20 advances energy security (India imports ~85% of its crude), cuts a huge import bill, lowers transport-sector emissions and lifts farm incomes, and that it was achieved ahead of the 2030 target. SIAM says the fuel is safe to use, that a "50% mileage crash" is misinformation, and that the scientifically measured drop is 2 to 4%. Opposition parties have separately alleged a conflict of interest, pointing to Gadkari-family links to ethanol businesses, an allegation he has not been charged over and which is noted here as a claim, not a finding.
🌍 Countries That Got Ethanol Right, and How

Ethanol blending works. The difference is sequence and consent: the successful programmes spent years, sometimes decades, building the vehicle fleet, giving drivers a choice at the pump, and pricing ethanol below petrol so people opted in. India delivered the mandate first and the choice never.

🇧🇷 Brazil
Pioneer · since 1975 · ~50 yrs
  • Proálcool programme after the 1973 oil shock, built gradually over five decades.
  • ~85% of new cars are flex-fuel; fleet and fuel moved in step.
  • Drivers choose E27 to E100 at the pump.
  • Ethanol priced below petrol, people switch at ~70% of petrol's price.
🇺🇸 United States
E10 standard · since 2005
  • E10 mainstreamed under the Renewable Fuel Standard (corn-based).
  • E15 and E85 are optional at 4,200+ stations via blender pumps.
  • Ethanol-free petrol still sold for older / small engines.
  • Ethanol content is labelled at the pump.
🇪🇺 European Union
E10 standard · phased
  • E10 standard in France, Germany & the UK; E5 still widely available.
  • Blends kept below 10% in many states over land-use concerns.
  • E5 protection grade retained for older cars.
  • Clear pump labelling across the bloc.
🇹🇭 Thailand
Gasohol grades · phased
  • Multiple "gasohol" grades, E10, E20, E85, offered side by side.
  • Backed by domestic feedstock and a consumer choice of blend.
  • Higher blends incentivised, not imposed.
🇮🇳 India
E20 mandate · 2025 · ~2 yrs
  • Hit E20 in 2025, 5 years early, then made it near-universal.
  • No choice of blend at the pump.
  • No price discount for the lower-energy fuel.
  • No ethanol label; flex-fuel vehicles arrive after the mandate.
📊 The Four Things Successful Programmes Did
  Decades to
build fleet
Choice of
blend at pump
Price cut for
ethanol
Ethanol
label
Brazil 🇧🇷YesYesYesYes
USA 🇺🇸YesYesYesYes
EU 🇪🇺YesYesNoYes
India 🇮🇳NoNoNoNo

The one-line contrast: Brazil, the US and the EU moved the vehicles and the consumer along with the fuel. India moved only the fuel, and made it compulsory.

Sources: Business Standard (Brazil ethanol history; Aug 2025 India to Brazil to US to EU comparison) · Business Today (18 Jun 2026) · Outlook India (Jul 2026) · Deccan Herald ("Ethanol leap: progress or pitfall") · Autopunditz (E85 global comparison) · Bloomberg (flex-fuel share).
For balance, the case for India's pace.
Supporters argue that waiting decades, Brazil-style, would have kept India dependent on imported crude and forgone farm-income and emissions gains; that a firm mandate was the fastest way to build an ethanol supply chain; and that flex-fuel launches now under way will, over time, give Indian buyers the same choice Brazilians enjoy. The open question the record poses is not whether to blend ethanol, but why the driver was asked to absorb the cost first, without the choice, discount or label the successful programmes provided.
📋 Exam Leaks · Paper Leak Tracker 2021 to 2026
📌 India Exam Paper Leak Scandal · One Resignation, Institutions Largely Unreformed
Minister resigned
India Exam Paper Leak Scandal · NEET, UGC-NET, Police & State PSC Papers Leaked, Systemic Failure of NTA & Exam Bodies
Paper Leak Accountability ⚖ Supreme Court · CBI · NTA
  • NEET-UG 2026: Physics paper leaked; roughly 22.7 lakh students sat a re-examination. Weeks of Jantar Mantar protests and a 26-day hunger strike by Sonam Wangchuk followed, demanding Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation.
  • Outcome, 25 July 2026: Pradhan resigned; Pralhad Joshi took additional charge of the ministry. FIRs against protesters were dropped and compensation promised to victims' families. We have not found evidence that any NTA official has faced formal action.
  • NEET-UG 2024: Paper leaked in Patna, Godhra & Hazaribagh for ₹30 to 32 lakh; roughly 24 lakh students affected that year. CBI arrested coaching operators. SC, "you are ruining futures of millions."
  • UGC-NET June 2024: Leaked on Darknet/Telegram, exam scrapped within 24 hrs; 9.08 lakh candidates affected. Shifted away from NTA.
  • UP Police Constable 2024: 48 lakh candidates; paper leaked from Ahmedabad warehouse. Exam cancelled, re-exam held, 244 arrested.
  • Pattern: BPSC, Rajasthan SI, TSPSC, Bihar Constable, 50+ leaks since 2020. A 2024 anti-paper-leak law was enacted; institutional (NTA-level) accountability remains the open question.
📋 Paper Leak Tracker · NEET, CBSE & All Major Exams · 2021 to 2026
Coverage: NEET-UG · CBSE Class 10 & 12 Boards · UGC-NET · JEE · State PSC/Police exams. Each row shows who headed the Education Ministry at the time, whether investigation was ordered, and the outcome. The Union Ministry of Education oversees NTA (NEET/JEE/UGC-NET) and CBSE directly.
Year Exam / Board Agency Minister of Education
(at time of leak)
Candidates What Happened Investigation & Result Status
2026 NEET-UG 2026
National medical entrance
NTA Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education Jul 2021 to Jul 2026, resigned
~24 lakh Patna/Godhra leak 24 hrs before exam via WhatsApp solver networks. ₹30 to 32L per student. 200+ students received solved papers in Bihar, Gujarat, Jharkhand. CBI FIR; NTA DG removed; SC suo motu intervened; partial re-test ordered; Bihar SIT arrested 18 incl. coaching owner & NTA insider. CBI Active
2024 CBSE Class 10, Hindi & Maths
Board examinations
CBSE / MoE Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education
~22 lakh Hindi paper (Feb 2024) leaked on WhatsApp within 30 mins of distribution at centres in Delhi, Rajasthan & UP. Maths paper leaked at select Rajasthan centres. CBSE initially denied, then acknowledged "irregularities." CBSE ordered re-exam for Hindi in select regions. Delhi Police FIR; centre supervisors suspended. No independent probe; CBSE chairman not questioned. Partial Re-exam
2024 NEET-UG 2024
National medical entrance
NTA Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education
24 lakh Patna gang leaked paper night before; 67 perfect scorers (720/720), statistically impossible. Grace marks for 1,563 candidates found irregular. Bihar police arrested 13 incl. Hazaribagh jail superintendent. SC refused full cancellation. Grace marks cancelled; re-test for affected. NTA DG removed. CBI took over. No senior NTA/MoE official charge-sheeted. Probe Ongoing
2024 UGC-NET June 2024
JRF / Asst Prof eligibility
NTA Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education
9.08 lakh Paper surfaced on Darknet 24 hrs before exam. I4C detected and alerted MoE. Exam was conducted, cancelled next day once leak confirmed. 317 cities affected. Cancelled. CBI probe. Re-exam Sept 2024 under CBSE (not NTA). NTA restructuring announced. No senior arrests. Re-exam Done
2024 UP Police Constable
60,244 posts
UPPBPB State, Yogi Adityanath
UP Chief Minister
48 lakh Ahmedabad warehouse leak via WhatsApp before Feb exam. Solved papers circulated across multiple states. Cancelled. STF probe; re-exam Aug 2024; 244 arrested. Re-exam Done
2024 BPSC 70th CCE
Bihar civil services
BPSC State, Nitish Kumar
Bihar Chief Minister
4.8 lakh Bapu Pariksha Parisar centre leak; weeks of student protests across Patna. Single centre re-exam only; full cancellation denied; protesters lathi-charged. Partial Re-exam
2023 CBSE Class 12, Economics
Board examination
CBSE / MoE Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education
~14 lakh Economics paper leaked via Telegram hours before exam (Mar 2023). Circulated across Rajasthan, Delhi & Haryana coaching networks. Students at centres received solved papers on phones. CBSE acknowledged leak. Delhi Police arrested 2 (coaching employees). No re-exam; internal moderation only. No MoE accountability statement. Closed, No Re-exam
2023 TSPSC Group-1
Telangana civil services
TSPSC State, K. Chandrashekar Rao
Telangana CM (BRS)
25,000+ Leaked from commission's own server; chairman's son arrested. Cancelled; chairman removed; CID arrested IT officer. Chargesheeted. Chargesheeted
2022 to 23 Rajasthan Multiple Exams
REET, SI, Patwari, Teacher
RPSC / RSMSSB State, Ashok Gehlot
Rajasthan CM (Cong.)
40+ lakh 15 leak cases in 2021 to 22; organised paper mafia with political links alleged. 615 arrested in 33 cases; SIT formed 2023. Main gang leaders still on bail. SIT Ongoing
2022 CBSE Class 12 Term-1, Psychology, PE, Business Studies
Board exam
CBSE / MoE Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education (Jul 2021 to Jul 2026, resigned)
~15 lakh Multiple papers leaked 30 to 45 mins before start on WhatsApp/Telegram in Delhi NCR & UP (Nov to Dec 2021 Term-1 exams). CBSE denied systemic leak; no FIR; no re-exam. Zero accountability action by MoE or CBSE. Denied / Closed
2021 NEET-UG 2021
National medical entrance
NTA Dharmendra Pradhan
Min. of Education (Jul 2021 to Jul 2026, resigned)
16.14 lakh Jodhpur gang sourced paper from NTA printing press contractor; sold to candidates in Rajasthan & Haryana. Gang active since 2018. Rajasthan SIT arrested 7 (printing press employees, solver coordinator). CBI not involved. No NTA internal inquiry; results not cancelled. Treated as isolated, no systemic review until 2024. SIT Chargesheeted
2021 UPTET 2021
UP teacher eligibility
UPMSP State, Yogi Adityanath
UP Chief Minister
21 lakh Delhi printing firm leaked paper hours before exam; director arrested. Cancelled hours before start; re-exam Jan 2022. Re-exam Done
🏛 Ministry Accountability, Who Was in Charge & What They Did
Minister of Education Tenure Major Leaks During Tenure Action Taken Resigned / Sacked?
Dharmendra Pradhan
BJP · Rajya Sabha, Odisha
Jul 2021, 25 Jul 2026 NEET 2021, 2024, 2026 · UGC-NET 2024 · CBSE leaks 2022, 2023, 2024 · UP Constable · BPSC Defended NTA in Parliament (May 2024). Announced NTA restructuring (Jul 2024) after SC pressure. Refused full NEET 2024 cancellation. Passed Public Examinations Act 2024, zero convictions under it as of Jun 2026. Yes, resigned 25 Jul 2026 after NEET-UG 2026 leak protests
Pralhad Joshi
BJP · Dharwad MP, Karnataka
26 Jul 2026, Present (additional charge) None reported yet Took charge the day after Pradhan resigned; also holds Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution and New & Renewable Energy. Chaired a first review of the ministry on 26 Jul 2026. No full-time Education Minister named as of 26 Sept 2026. Serving
Ramesh Pokhriyal 'Nishank'
BJP · Haridwar MP, Uttarakhand
Jul 2019, Jul 2021 NEET/JEE COVID postponements · Early state exam leaks No accountability action on leaks. Resigned Jul 2021 citing health. Resigned (health)
Why It Keeps Happening: 80% of leaks originate at printing press or transport handoff. Coaching mafia pays ₹5 to 32L per student and directly recruits NTA/printing press insiders. CBSE leaks are routinely denied or minimised, rarely trigger re-exams. The Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act 2024 prescribes 3 to 10 yr jail & ₹1 Cr fine, but zero senior convictions as of Jun 2026.
Sources: SC orders · CBI press releases · NTA circulars · MoE Parliament statements · The Hindu · Indian Express · Bar & Bench · Careers360 · PTI